LETTER XLVIII. 73
others. I will only mention the Apostle
Paul, whose words seem to me, as often as
I hear them, to be not words, but peals of
thunder. Read his epistles, and especially
those addressed to the Romans, to the Gala-
tians, and to the Ephesians, in all of which
he stands in the thick of the battle, and you
will see how skilful and how careful he is
in the proofs which he draws from the Old
Testament, and how warily he cloaks the
object which he has in view. His words
seem simplicity itself: the expressions of a
guileless and unsophisticated person — one who has no skill either to plan a dilemma
or to avoid it. Still, whichever way you
look, they are thunderbolts. His pleading
halts, yet he carries every point which he
takes up. He turns his back upon his foe
only to overcome him; he simulates flight,
but only that he may slay. He, then, if any
one, ought to be calumniated; we should
speak thus to him: "The proofs which you have used against the Jews or against other
heretics bear a different meaning in their
own contexts to that which they bear in
your epistles. We see passages taken cap-
tive by your pen and pressed into service to
win you a victory which in the volumes
from which they are taken have no contro-
versial bearing at all." May he not reply to us in the words of the Saviour: "I have
one mode of speech for those that are without
and another for those that are within ; the
crowds hear my parables, but their interpre-
tation is for my disciples alone " ? ' The Lord puts questions to the Pharisees, but
does not elucidate them. To teach a dis-
ciple is one thing; to vanquish an opponent,
another. " My mystery is for me," says the
prophet; "my mystery is for me and for them that are mine."2
14. You are indignant with me because I
have merely silenced Jovinian and not in-
structed him. You, do I say? Nay, rather,
they who grieve to hear him anathematized,
and who impeach their own pretended ortho-
doxy by eulogizing in another the heresy
which they hold themselves. I should have
asked him, forsooth, to surrender peaceably !
I had no right to disregard his struggles and
to drag him against his will into the bonds
of truth! I might use such language had
the desire of victory induced me to say
anything counter to the rule laid down in
Scripture, and had I taken the line — so often
adopted by strong men in controversy — of
justifying the means by the result. As it is,
however, I have been an exponent of the
1 Matt. xiii. 10-17. 2 Isa. xxiv. 16, Vul,
apostle rather than a dogmatist on my own
account; and my function has been simply
that of a commentator. Anything, there-
fore, which seems a hard saying should be
imputed to the writer expounded by me
rather than to me the expounder; unless,
indeed, he spoke otherwise than he is repre-
sented to have done, and I have by an unfair
interpretation wrested the plain meaning of
his words. If any one charges me with this
disingenuousness let him prove his charge
from the Scriptures themselves.
I have said in my book,1 "If 'it is good
for a man not to touch a woman,' then it is bad for him to touch one, for bad, and bad
only, is the opposite of good. But, if
though bad it is made venial, then it is al-
lowed to prevent something which would be
worse than bad," and so on down to the commencement of the next chapter. The
above is my comment upon the apostle's
words: " It is good for a man not to touch a woman. Nevertheless, to avoid fornication,
let every man have his own wife, and let
every woman have her own husband. " " In what way does my meaning differ from that
intended by the apostle ? Except that where
he speaks decidedly I do so with hesitation.
He defines a dogma, I hazard an inquiry.
He openly says: "It is good for a man not
to touch a woman." I timidly ask if it is good for a man not to touch one. If I thus
waver, I cannot be said to speak positively.
He says: " It is good not to touch." I add
what is a possible antithesis to "good."
And immediately afterwards I speak thus:3
" Notice the apostle's carefulness. He
does not say: 'It is good for a man not to
have a wife, ' but, 'It is good for a man not to
touch a woman' ; as if there is danger in the
very touching of one — danger which he who
touches cannot escape." You see, therefore,
that I am not expounding the law as to hus-
bands and wives, but simply discussing the
general question of sexual intercourse — how in comparison with chastity and virginity,
the life of angels, " It is good for a man not
to touch a woman."
"Vanity of vanities," says the Preacher,
"all is vanity. "4 But if all created things
are good,5 as being the handiwork of a good Creator, how comes it that all things are
vanity? If the earth is vanity, are the
heavens vanity too? — and the angels, the
thrones, the dominations, the powers, and the
rest of the virtues ? 6 No ; if things which are
1 Ag. Jov. i. 7. 2 i Cor. vii. i, 2. 3 Ag. Jfov. i. 7.
4 Eccles. i. 2. & Gen. i. 31 ; i Tim. iv. 4.
6 Col. i. 16. Cf. Milton, P. L. v. 601.