§11. The sophistry which he employs to prove our acknowledgment that he had been tried,
and that the confession of his faith had not been unimpeached, is feeble.
He objects to sophistries in others; see the sort of care he takes himself that his proofs
shall be real ones. Our Master said, in the book which he addressed to him, that at the time
when our cause was ruined, Eunomius won Cyzicus as the prize of his blasphemy. What
then does this detector of sophistry do? He fastens at once on that word prize, and declares
that we on our side confess that he made an apology, that he won thereby, that he gained
the prize of victory by these efforts; and he frames his argument into a syllogism consisting
as he thinks of unanswerable propositions. But we will quote word for word what he has
written. ‘If a prize is the recognition and the crown of victory, and a trial implies a victory,
and, as also inseparable from itself, an accusation, then that man who grants (in argument)
the prize must necessarily allow that there was a defence.’ What then is our answer to that?
We do not deny that he fought this wretched battle of impiety with a most vigorous energy,
and that he went a very long distance beyond his fellows in these perspiring efforts against
the truth; but we will not allow that he obtained the victory over his opponents; but only
that as compared with those who were running the same as himself through heresy into
error he was foremost in the number of his lies and so gained the prize of Cyzicus in return
for high attainments in evil, beating all who for the same prize combated the Truth; and
47
that for this victory of blasphemy his name was blazoned loud and clear when Cyzicus was
selected for him by the umpires of his party as the reward of his extravagance. This is the
statement of our opinion, and this we allowed; our contention now that Cyzicus was the
prize of a heresy, not the successful result of a defence, shews it. Is this anything like his own
mess of childish sophistries, so that he can thereby hope to have grounds for proving the
fact of his trial and his defence? His method is like that of a man in a drinking bout, who
has made away with more strong liquor than the rest, and having then claimed the pool
from his fellow-drunkards should attempt to make this victory a proof of having won some
case in the law courts. That man might chop the same sort of logic. ‘If a prize is the recogni-
tion and the crown of victory, and a law-trial implies a victory and, as also inseparable from
itself, an accusation, then I have won my suit, since I have been crowned for my powers of
drinking in this bout.’
One would certainly answer to such a boaster that a trial in court is a very different
thing from a wine-contest, and that one who wins with the glass has thereby no advantage
over his legal adversaries, though he get a beautiful chaplet of flowers. No more, therefore,
has the man who has beaten his equals in the advocacy of profanity anything to show in
having won the prize for that, that he has won a verdict too. The testimony on our side that
he is first in profanity is no plea for his imaginary ‘apology.’ If he did speak it before the
court, and, having so prevailed over his adversaries, was honoured with Cyzicus for that,
then he might have some occasion for using our own words against ourselves; but as he is
The sophistry which he employs to prove our acknowledgment that he had been tried, and that the confession of his faith had not been unimpeached, is feeble.
86
The sophistry which he employs to prove our acknowledgment that he had been…