who considered it to be untrue and an invention of Socrates to please the Novatians. Natalis
Alexander often maintains erroneous opinions, and on the present question he deserves no
confidence. If, as St. Epiphanius relates, the Novatians maintained that the clergy might be
married exactly like the laity, it cannot be said that Socrates shared that opinion, since he
says, or rather makes Paphnutius say, that, according to ancient tradition, those not married
at the time of ordination should not be so subsequently. Moreover, if it may be said that
Socrates had a partial sympathy with the Novatians, he certainly cannot be considered as
belonging to them, still less can he be accused of falsifying history in their favour. He may
sometimes have propounded erroneous opinions, but there is a great difference between
that and the invention of a whole story. Valesius especially makes use of the argument ex
silentio against Socrates. (a) Rufinus, he says, gives many particulars about Paphnutius in
his History of the Church; he mentions his martyrdom, his miracles, and the Emperor’s
reverence for him, but not a single word of the business about celibacy. (b) The name of
Paphnutius is wanting in the list of Egyptian bishops present at the Synod. These two argu-
ments of Valesius are weak; the second has the authority of Rufinus himself against it, who
expressly says that Bishop Paphnutius was present at the Council of Nicæa. If Valesius
means by lists only the signatures at the end of the acts of the Council, this proves nothing;
for these lists are very imperfect, and it is well known that many bishops whose names are
not among these signatures were present at Nicæa. This argument ex silentio is evidently
insufficient to prove that the anecdote about Paphnutius must be rejected as false, seeing
that it is in perfect harmony with the practice of the ancient Church, and especially of the
Greek Church, on the subject of clerical marriages. On the other hand, Thomassin pretends
that there was no such practice, and endeavours to prove by quotations from St. Epiphanius,
St. Jerome, Eusebius, and St. John Chrysostom, that even in the East priests who were married
at the time of their ordination were prohibited from continuing to live with their wives.
The texts quoted by Thomassin prove only that the Greeks gave especial honour to priests
living in perfect continency, but they do not prove that this continence was a duty incumbent
upon all priests; and so much the less, as the fifth and twenty-fifth Apostolic canons, the
fourth canon of Gangra, and the thirteenth of the Trullan Synod, demonstrate clearly enough
what was the universal custom of the Greek Church on this point. Lupus and Phillips ex-
plained the words of Paphnutius in another sense. According to them, the Egyptian bishop
was not speaking in a general way; he simply desired that the contemplated law should not
include the subdeacons. But this explanation does not agree with the extracts quoted from
Socrates, Sozomen, and Gelasius, who believe Paphnutius intended deacons and priests as
well.
124
Proposed Action on Clerical Celibacy.