On Bk. III.
chap. 39, § 1 (note 1, continued).
Since the above note was in type
Resch’s important work on the
Agrapha
(von Gebhardt and
Harnack’s
Texte und
Untersuchungen
, Bd. V. Heft 4) has come to
hand. On p. 27 sq. he discusses at considerable length the sources of
the Synoptic Gospels. He accepts the theory which is most widely
adopted by New-Testament critics, that the synoptic tradition as
contained in our Synoptic Gospels rests upon an original Gospel of Mark
(nearly if not quite identical with our present Gospel of Mark) and a
pre-canonical Hebrew Gospel. In agreement with such critics he draws a
sharp distinction between this original Hebrew Gospel and our canonical
Greek Matthew, while at the same time recognizing that the latter
reproduces that original more fully
than either of the other
Gospels does. This original Hebrew he then identifies with the
λόγια
referred to by Papias as composed by Matthew in the Hebrew
tongue (see Bk. III. chap. 39, § 16); that is, with the
traditional Hebrew Gospel of Matthew (see
ibid
. chap. 24, note
5). The arguments which he urges in support of this position are very
strong. Handmann regards the Gospel according to the Hebrews as the
second original source of the synoptic tradition, alongside of the
Ur-Marcus, and even suggests its identification with the
λόγια
of Papias, and yet denies its identity with the Hebrew
Matthew. On the other hand, Resch regards the Hebrew Matthew, which he
identifies with the
λόγια
of Papias,
as the second original source of the synoptic tradition, alongside of
Mark or the Ur-Marcus, and yet, like Handmann, though on entirely
different grounds, denies the identity of the Gospel according to the
Hebrews with the Hebrew Matthew. Their positions certainly tend to
confirm my suggestion that the Hebrew Matthew and the Gospel according
to the Hebrews were originally identical (see above, Bk. III. chap. 27,
note 8).