Chapter 19.—Of Lucretia, Who Put an End to Her Life Because of the Outrage Done
Her.
This, then, is our position, and it seems sufficiently lucid. We maintain that when a
woman is violated while her soul admits no consent to the iniquity, but remains inviolably
chaste, the sin is not hers, but his who violates her. But do they against whom we have to
defend not only the souls, but the sacred bodies too of these outraged Christian captives,—do
they, perhaps, dare to dispute our position? But all know how loudly they extol the purity
of Lucretia, that noble matron of ancient Rome. When King Tarquin’s son had violated
her body, she made known the wickedness of this young profligate to her husband Collatinus,
and to Brutus her kinsman, men of high rank and full of courage, and bound them by an
oath to avenge it. Then, heart-sick, and unable to bear the shame, she put an end to her
life. What shall we call her? An adulteress, or chaste? There is no question which she was.
Not more happily than truly did a declaimer say of this sad occurrence: “Here was a marvel:
there were two, and only one committed adultery.” Most forcibly and truly spoken. For
this declaimer, seeing in the union of the two bodies the foul lust of the one, and the chaste
will of the other, and giving heed not to the contact of the bodily members, but to the wide
diversity of their souls, says: “There were two, but the adultery was committed only by one.”
But how is it, that she who was no partner to the crime bears the heavier punishment
of the two? For the adulterer was only banished along with his father; she suffered the ex-
treme penalty. If that was not impurity by which she was unwillingly ravished, then this is
not justice by which she, being chaste, is punished. To you I appeal, ye laws and judges of
Rome. Even after the perpetration of great enormities, you do not suffer the criminal to be
slain untried. If, then, one were to bring to your bar this case, and were to prove to you that
a woman not only untried, but chaste and innocent, had been killed, would you not visit
the murderer with punishment proportionably severe? This crime was committed by Lu-
cretia; that Lucretia so celebrated and lauded slew the innocent, chaste, outraged Lucretia.
Pronounce sentence. But if you cannot, because there does not appear any one whom you
can punish, why do you extol with such unmeasured laudation her who slew an innocent
and chaste woman? Assuredly you will find it impossible to defend her before the judges
of the realms below, if they be such as your poets are fond of representing them; for she is
among those
“Who guiltless sent themselves to doom,
And all for loathing of the day,
In madness threw their lives away.”
And if she with the others wishes to return,
“Fate bars the way: around their keep
The slow unlovely waters creep,
Of Lucretia, Who Put an End to Her Life Because of the Outrage Done Her.
47
Of Lucretia, Who Put an End to Her Life Because of the Outrage Done Her