maintains, by receiving them into the Church without baptism. That it was, moreover, the
custom that they should be so received, is testified both by Cyprian himself in many passages,
and by some bishops in this Council. Whence it is evident that, if heretics have not baptism,
the Church of Christ of those days was full of traitors, who upheld them by receiving them
in this way. I would urge, therefore, that we plead our cause in common against the charge
of treason which they cannot disavow, and therein our special case will be argued against
the charge of delivering the books, which they could not prove against us. But let us argue
the point as though they had convicted us; and what we shall answer jointly to those who
urge against both of us the general treason of our forefathers, that we will answer to these
men who urge against us that our forefathers gave up the sacred books. For as we were dead
because our forefathers delivered up the books, which caused them to divide themselves
from us, so both we and they themselves are dead through the treason of our forefathers,
from whom both we and they are sprung. But since they say they live, they hold that that
treason does not in any way affect them, therefore neither are we affected by the delivery of
the books. And it should be observed that, according to them, the treason is indisputable:
while, according to us, there is no truth either in the former charge of treason, because we
say that heretics also may have the baptism of Christ; nor in the latter charge of delivering
the books, because in that they were themselves beaten. They have therefore no reason for
separating themselves by the wicked sin of schism, because, if our forefathers were not guilty
of delivering up the books, as we say, there is no charge which can affect us at all; but if they
were guilty of the sin, as these men say, then it is just as far from affecting us as the sin of
those other traitors is from affecting either us or them. And hence, since there is no charge
that can implicate us from the unrighteousness of our forefathers, the charge arising against
them from their own schism is manifestly proved.
922
Chapter 2