before this, at Sardica in 343 a.d. But in a distant province, aided by the application of suffi-
cient pressure, they might serve their turn, and if the Emperor could obtain his enemy’s
condemnation, and that in a region whose theological sympathies were notoriously on his
side, a great step would be gained towards his expulsion from Egypt. No time was lost. In
October, 353, a Council was called at Arles to consider the charges. It suited Constantius’
purpose well that Saturninus of Arles, bishop of the most important see in Gaul, and the
natural president, was both a courtier and an Arian. He did his work well. The assembled
bishops believed, or were induced to profess that they believed, that the charges against
Athanasius were not made in the interests of his theological opponents, and that the Emper-
or’s account of them was true. The decision, condemning the accused, was almost unanimous.
Even the representative of Liberius of Rome consented, to be disavowed on his return; and
only one bishop, Paulinus of Treves, suffered exile for resistance. He may have been the
only advocate for Athanasius, or Constantius may have thought that one example would
suffice to terrify the episcopate of Gaul into submission. It is impossible to say whether
Hilary was present at the Council or no. It is not probable that he was absent: and his ignor-
xi
ance, even later, on important points in the dispute shows that he may well have given an
honest verdict against Athanasius. The new ruler’s word had been given that he was guilty;
nothing can yet have been known against Constantius and much must have been hoped
from him. It was only natural that he should obtain the desired decision. Two years followed,
during which the Emperor was too busy with warfare on the frontiers of Gaul to proceed
further in the matter of Athanasius. But in the Autumn of 355 he summoned a Council at
Milan, a city whose influence over Gaul was so great that it might almost be called the eccle-
siastical capital of that country. Here again strong pressure was used, and the verdict given
as Constantius desired. Hilary was not present at this Council; he was by this time aware of
the motives of Constantius and the courtier bishops, and would certainly have shared in
the opposition offered, and probably in the exile inflicted upon three of the leaders in it.
These were Dionysius of Milan, who disappears from history, his place being taken by Hilary’s
future enemy, Auxentius, and Eusebius of Vercelli and Lucifer of Cagliari, both of whom
were to make their mark in the future.
By this time Hilary had definitely taken his side, and it will be well to consider his relation
to the parties in the controversy. And first as to Arianism. As we have seen, Arian prelates
were now in possession of the two great sees of Arles and Milan in his own neighbourhood;
and Arianisers of different shades, or at least men tolerant of Arianism, held a clear majority
of the Eastern bishoprics, except in the wholly Catholic Egypt. But it is certain that, in the
West at any rate, the fundamental difference of the Arian from the Catholic position was
not generally recognised. Arian practice and Arian practical teaching was indistinguishable
from Catholic; and unless ultimate principles were questioned, Catholic clergy might work,
and the multitudes of Catholic laity might live and die, without knowing that their bishop’s
19
The Life and Writings of St. Hilary of Poitiers.