argument, rather for the doctrinal. The Catholic aim is their conversion, whether by the
persuasion of argument or the correction of laws. They should remember the mixed nature
of the Church, and that mere contact with evil does not defile. If you hold to Christ, hold
also to His Church; you kill us who seek to tell you the truth, and do not want you to perish
in evil. May God vindicate us and his cause by slaying your errors and making you rejoice
with us in the truth.
On the death of Proculeianus, Macrobius succeeded to the see of Hippo Regius. Augustin
hears that he is about to rebaptize a subdeacon (Rusticianus) who under discipline left the
Catholics. Augustin urges him [Ep. cvi.], c. 409, not to do this by his desire to have life in
God, and to please God by not making the sacraments vain, and by his hope of not being
separated from the body of Christ eternally. The Donatists have admitted the validity of
baptism as administered by Felicianus and Primianus, why then rebaptize others? and begs
him to search that case as a test of the whole matter.
Maximus and Theodore had been commissioned to deliver the previous letter to Bishop
Macrobius. He at first declined to listen to its reading, but was at last persuaded to attend,
and in reply said: It was his duty to receive all who came, and to give faith to those who
asked it. Into the question about Primian he would not enter, because of his own recent
ordination; he was not a judge of his father, and he would remain in what his predecessors
had accepted. These replies were conveyed to Augustin in the letter cvii. (c. 409) by the two
commissioners.
In still further hope of reaching Bishop Macrobius, Augustin addressed another epistle,
(cviii. ) c. 409, to him in answer to the objections offered by him at the interview with the
commissioners. 1. As to the point that he must receive those who come and give them the
faith they ask: Augustin proposes the case of some one who has received the rite in their
391
communion, but had been separated from it for a time, and having returned, conscientiously
desires to be rebaptized; Macrobius, according to his objection, could not repeat the rite,
but would proceed to instruct him. Why repeat it when Augustin administers it? May be
you will quote, "keep thyself from strange water and do not drink from a strange fountain."
How then will you explain the reception of Felicianus? 2. As to the second conclusion, that
you would remain in the faith of your predecessors: It is a pity for a young man of good
parts to say so; nothing compels you to remain in evil; you had better be in the Church
which began in Jerusalem and spread thence through the world. 3. And if you will not judge
your fathers why judge my fathers? If not Primian, why Cæcilian? Why deny us to be
brethren? why rend the body? why extinguish the baptism of Christ, who baptizes with the
Spirit, and who gave Himself for the Church? Yet your colleagues in effect do yield to the
truth in their recognition of the Maximianists. Judge not the evil but do judge what was
good in Primian. That act of his, the reception of the Maximianists, absolves the nations
who are ignorant of what you accuse us. He then traces the whole development of that
671
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.