Gregory of
Nyssa Against Eunomius.
Letter I.
Gregory
to his brother Peter, Bishop of Sebasteia.
Having with difficulty obtained
a little leisure, I have been able to recover from bodily fatigue on my
return from Armenia, and to collect the sheets of my reply to Eunomius
which was suggested by your wise advice; so that my work is now
arranged in a complete treatise, which can be read between covers.
However, I have not written against both his pamphlets
56
; even the leisure for that was not granted;
for the person who lent me the heretical volume most uncourteously sent
for it again, and allowed me no time either to write it out or to study
it. In the short space of seventeen days it was impossible to be
prepared to answer both his attacks.
Owing to its somehow having
become notorious that we had laboured to answer this blasphemous
manifesto, many persons possessing some zeal for the Truth have
importuned me about it: but I have thought it right to prefer you in
your wisdom before them all, to advise me whether to consign this work
to the public, or to take some other course. The reason why I hesitate
is this. When our saintly Basil fell asleep, and I received the legacy
of Eunomius’ controversy, when my heart was hot within me with
bereavement, and, besides this deep sorrow for the common loss of the
church, Eunomius had not confined himself to the various topics which
might pass as a defence of his views, but had spent the chief part of
his energy in laboriously-written abuse of our father in God. I was
exasperated with this, and there were passages where the flame of my
heart-felt indignation burst out against this writer. The public have
pardoned us for much else, because we have been apt in showing patience
in meeting lawless attacks, and as far as possible have practised that
restraint in feeling which the saint has taught us; but I had fears
lest from what we have now written against this opponent the reader
should get the idea that we were very raw controversialists, who lost
our temper directly at insolent abuse. Perhaps, however, this suspicion
about us will be disarmed by remembering that this display of anger is
not on our own behalf, but because of insults levelled against our
father in God; and that it is a case in which mildness would be more
unpardonable than anger.
If, then, the first part of my
treatise should seem somewhat outside the controversy, the following
explanation of it will, I think, be accepted by a reader who can judge
fairly. It was not right to leave undefended the reputation of our
noble saint, mangled as it was by the opponent’s blasphemies, any
more than it was convenient to let this battle in his behalf be spread
diffusely along the whole thread of the discussion; besides, if any one
reflects, these pages do really form part of the controversy. Our
adversary’s treatise has two separate arms, viz. to abuse us and
to controvert sound doctrine; and therefore ours too must show a double
front. But for the sake of clearness, and in order that the thread of
the discussion upon matters of the Faith should not be cut by
parentheses, consisting of answers to their personal abuse, we have
separated our work into two parts, and devoted ourselves in the first
to refute these charges: and then we have grappled as best we might
with that which they have advanced against the Faith. Our treatise also
contains, in addition to a refutation of their heretical views, a
dogmatic exposition of our own teaching; for it would be a most
shameful want of spirit, when our foes make no concealment of their
blasphemy, not to be bold in our statement of the Truth.
56
both
his pamphlets.
The ‘sheets’
which Gregory says that he has collected are the 12 Books that follow.
They are written in reply to Eunomius’ pamphlet, ‘Apologia
Apologiæ,’ itself a reply to Basil’s Refutation. The
other pamphlet of Eunomius seems to have come out during the
composition of Gregory’s 12 Books: and was afterwards answered by
the latter in a second 12th Book, but not now, because of the shortness
of the time in which he had a copy of the ‘heretical
volume’ in his hands. The two last books of the five which go
under the title of Basil’s Refutation are considered on good
grounds to have been Gregory’s, and to have formed that short
reply to Eunomius which he read, at the Council of Constantinople, to
Gregory of Nazianzen and Jerome (
d. vir. illust.
c. 128). Then
he worked upon this longer reply. Thus there were in all three works of
Gregory corresponding to the three attacks of Eunomius upon the
Trinity.