499
Chapter XXXIII.
For when they have heard from us something to this effect—that when the mortal passes
into life it follows necessarily that, as that first birth leads only to the existence of mortality,
another birth should be discovered, a birth which neither begins nor ends with corruption,
but one which conducts the person begotten to an immortal existence, in order that, as what
is begotten of a mortal birth has necessarily a mortal subsistence, so from a birth which admits
not corruption that which is born may be superior to the corruption of death; when, I say,
they have heard this and the like from us, and are besides instructed as to the pro-
cess,—namely that it is prayer and the invocation of heavenly grace, and water, and faith,
by which the mystery of regeneration is accomplished,—they still remain incredulous and
have an eye only for the outward and visible, as if that which is operated corporeally2019
concurred not with the fulfilment of God’s promise. How, they ask, can prayer and the in-
vocation of Divine power over the water be the foundation of life in those who have been
thus initiated? In reply to them, unless they be of a very obstinate disposition, one single
consideration suffices to bring them to an acquiescence in our doctrine. For let us in our
turn ask them about that process of the carnal generation which every one can notice. How
does that something which is cast for the beginnings of the formation of a living being become
a Man? In that case, most certainly, there is no method whatever that can discover for us,
by any possible reasoning, even the probable truth. For what correlation is there between
the definition of man and the quality observable in that something? Man, when once he is
put together, is a reasoning and intellectual being, capable of thought and knowledge; but
that something is to be observed only in its quality of humidity, and the mind grasps nothing
in it beyond that which is seen by the sense of sight. The reply, therefore, which we might
expect to receive from those whom we questioned as to how it is credible that a man is
compounded from that humid element, is the very reply which we make when questioned
about the regeneration that takes place through the water. Now in that other case any one
so questioned has this reply ready at hand, that that element becomes a man by a Divine
power, wanting which, the element is motionless and inoperative. If, therefore, in that in-
stance the subordinate matter does not make the man, but the Divine power changes that
visible thing into a man’s nature, it would be utterly unfair for them, when in the one case
they testify to such power in God, in this other department to suppose that the Deity is too
weak to accomplish His will. What is there common, they ask, between water and life? What
is there common, we ask them in return, between humidity and God’s image? In that case
2019 σωματικῶς: with a general reference both to the recipient, the words (the “form”), and the water (the
“matter,” in the Aristotelian sense). Cf. questions in Private Baptism of Infants:and Hampden’s Bampton Lectures,
p. 336 n.
Chapter XXXIII
941
Chapter XXXIII