CHAP. XVIII.] WHETHER TPJNITY OR ONE PERSON APPEARED. 77
see " ? When men sleep, are they then not men ? Or cannot
He, who can fashion the likeness of a body to signify Him-
self through the visions of dreamers, also fashion that same
bodily creature to signify Himself to the eyes of those who
are awake ? Whereas His own very substance, whereby He
Himself is that which He is, cannot be shown by any bodily
likeness to one who sleeps, or by any bodily appearance to
one who is awake ; but this not of the Father only, but also
of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. And certainly, as to
those who are moved by the visions of waking men to believe
that not the Father, bat only the Son, or the Holy Spirit,
appeared to the corporeal sight of men,—to omit the great
extent of the sacred pages, and their manifold interpretation,
such that no one of sound reason ought to affirm that the
person of the Father was nowhere shown to the eyes ofwaking
men by any corporeal appearance ;—but, as I said, to omit
this, what do they say of our fatherAbraham,who was certainly
awake and ministering, when, after Scripture had premised,
" The Lord appeared unto Abraham," not one, or two, but
three men appeared to him ; no one of whom is said to
have stood prominently above the others, no one more than
the others to have shone with greater glory, or to have acted
more authoritatively ?
^
35. Wherefore, since in that our threefold division we
determined to inquire,^ first, whether the Father, or the Son,
or the Holy Spirit ; or whether sometimes the Father, some-
times the Son, sometimes the Holy Spirit ; or whether, with-
out any distinction of persons, as it is said, the one and only
God, that is, the Trinity itself, appeared to the fathers through
those forms of the creature : now that we have examined, so
far as appeared to be sufficient, what places of the Holy
Scriptures we could, a modest and cautious consideration of
divine mysteries leads, as far as I can judge, to no other con-
clusion, unless that we may not rashly affirm which person of
the Trinity appeared to this or that of the fathers or the
prophets in some body or likeness of body, unless when the
context attaches to the narrative some probable intimations on
the subject. For the nature itself, or substance, or essence, or
^ Gen. xviii. 1. 2 ggg above, chap. vii.