who condemn Him, and questions why by His own power He pardons the sins of men? for
it says, “Jesus, seeing their thoughts1308.” And of the Holy Spirit also, Peter says to Ananias,
“Why hath Satan filled thine heart, to lie to the Holy Ghost?1309” showing that the Holy
Spirit was a true witness, aware of what Ananias had dared to do in secret, and by Whom
the manifestation of the secret was made to Peter. For Ananias became a thief of his own
goods, secretly, as he thought, from all men, and concealing his sin: but the Holy Spirit at
the same moment was in Peter, and detected his intent, dragged down as it was to avarice,
and gave to Peter from Himself1310 the power of seeing the secret, while it is clear that He
could not have done this had He not been able to behold hidden things.
But some one will say that the proof of our argument does not yet regard the question.
For even if it were granted that the name of “Godhead” is a common name of the nature, it
would not be established that we should not speak of “Gods”: but by these arguments, on
the contrary, we are compelled to speak of “Gods”: for we find in the custom of mankind
that not only those who are partakers1311 in the same nature, but even any who may be of
the same business, are not, when they are many, spoken of in the singular; as we speak of
“many orators,” or “surveyors,” or “farmers,” or “shoemakers,” and so in all other cases. If,
indeed, Godhead were an appellation of nature, it would be more proper, according to the
argument laid down, to include the Three Persons in the singular number, and to speak of
“One God,” by reason of the inseparability and indivisibility of the nature: but since it has
been established by what has been said, that the term “Godhead” is significant of operation,
and not of nature, the argument from what has been advanced seems to turn to the contrary
conclusion, that we ought therefore all the more to call those “three Gods” who are contem-
plated in the same operation, as they say that one would speak of “three philosophers” or
“orators,” or any other name derived from a business when those who take part in the same
business are more than one.
I have taken some pains, in setting forth this view, to bring forward the reasoning on
behalf of the adversaries, that our decision may be the more firmly fixed, being strengthened
by the more elaborate contradictions. Let us now resume our argument.
334
As we have to a certain extent shown by our statement that the word “Godhead” is not
significant of nature but of operation, perhaps one might reasonably allege as a cause why,
in the case of men, those who share with one another in the same pursuits are enumerated
and spoken of in the plural, while on the other hand the Deity is spoken of in the singular
as one God and one Godhead, even though the Three Persons are not separated from the
1308 S. Matt. ix. 4
1309 Acts v. 3.
1310 Reading with Oehler παρ᾽ ἑαυτοῦ for δι᾽ ἑαυτοῦ.
1311 Reading κοινωνοὺς for κοινωνίας, with Oehler.
619
On 'Not Three Gods.'