διὰ τὸ ἔργον μέχρι θανάτου ἤγγισεν παραβολευσάμενος τῇ ψυχῇ, ἵνα ἀναπληρώσῃ τὸ ὑμῶν ὑστέρημα τῆς πρὸς με λειτουργίας.
III. 'Τὸ λοιπόν, ἀδελφοί μου, χαίρετε ἐν Κυρίῳ' Βολευσάμενος and παραβουλευσάμενος. The latter, which would mean 'having consulted amiss,' stands in the received text: but the evidence is strongly in favour of the former. Both words alike are very rare.
ἀναπληρώσῃ κ.τ.λ.] as in 1 Cor. xvi. 17 χαίρω ἐπὶ τῇ παρουσίᾳ Στεφινᾶ κ.τ.λ. ὅτι τὸ ὑμέτερον ὑστέρημα αὐτοὶ ἀνεπλήρωσαν: comp. Clem. Rom. § 38 δι' οὗ ἀναπληρωθῇ αὐτοῦ τὸ ὑστέρημα. So also ἀνταναπληροῦν in Col. i. 24 and προσαναπληροῦν in 2 Cor. xi. 9. τὸ ὑμῶν ὑστέρημα κ.τ.λ.] i.e. 'what your services towards me lacked to be complete,' in other words 'your personal ministrations,' as in 1 Cor. xvi. 17 just quoted. It seems plain from this expression that Epaphroditus illness was the consequence not of persecution but of over-exertion.
III. 1. 'And now, my brethren,
I must wish you farewell. Rejoice in the Lord. Forgive me, if I speak once more on an old topic. It is not irksome to me to speak, and it is safe for you to hear.' τὸ λοιπόν] 'for the rest,' i.e. 'finally, in conclusion.' With λοιπόν or τὸ λοιπόν St Paul frequently ushers in the concluding portion of his letters containing the practical exhortations; 1 Thess. iv. 1, 2 Thess. iii. 1, 2 Cor. xiii. 11, Ephes. vi. 10 (where however τοῦ λοιποῦ should probably be read). Sometimes this concluding portion is prolonged, as in the First Epistle to the Thessalonians, where it extends over two chapters. In the present instance the letter is interrupted, a fresh subject is introduced, the conclusion is for a time forgotten, and St Paul resumes his farewell injunctions later at iv. 8 τὸ λοιπόν, ἀδελφοί κ.τ.λ. See the introduction, p. 69 sq. In other passages λοιπόν and τὸ λοιπόν occur in reference to the approaching end of all things; as 1 Cor. vii. 29 ὁ καιρὸς συνεσταλμένος ἐστίν, τὸ λοιπόν ἵνα κ.τ.λ., Ign. Ephes. 11, Smyrn. 9. χαιρετε] 'farewell.' At the same time the word conveys an injunction to rejoice; see ii. 18, iv. 4, and the note on the latter passage.
τὰ αὐτά] 'the same things.' But to what does St Paul refer? To his own personal intercourse with the
Philippians? To messages delivered by his delegates? To previous letters not now extant? To some topic contained in this present epistle? The expression itself τὰ αὐτὰ γράφειν seems to limit the range of choice to written communications. The theory of an earlier letter or letter s, which seems to be supported by an expression of Polycarp (§ 3 ἀπὼν ὑμῖν ἔγραψεν ἐπιστολᾶς), will be considered in the detached note. At present it is sufficient to say that if the epistle itself supplies the requisite allusion, it is much more naturally sought here than elsewhere. On what subject then does this epistle dwell repeatedly?
Two answers will suggest themselves. (1) The duty of rejoicing. This topic is very prominent in the epistle: see the note on i. 4. It has occurred more than once already. It has the advantage also of appearing in the immediate context, χαίρετε ἐν Κυρίῳ. Nevertheless it seems inadequate to explain St Paul's language here. Such an injunction has no very direct bearing on the safety of the Philippians; its repetition could hardly be suspected of being irksome to the Apostle. The words seem obviously to refer to some actual or threatened evil, against which a reiterated warn-
τὰ αὐτὰ γράφειν ὑμῖν ἐμοὶ μὲν οὐκ ὀκνηρόν, ὑμῖν δὲ ἀσφαλές.
ing was necessary. (2) Such an evil existed in the dissensions among the Philippians. This topic either directly or indirectly has occupied a very considerable portion of the letter hitherto; and it appears again more than once before the close: see the introduction p. 67 sq. It is the Apostle's practice to conclude with a warning against the prevailing danger of his correspondents. The Corinthians are again reminded that 'the Lord cometh' (1 Cor. xvi. 22); the Galatians are told once more that 'circumcision is nothing and uncircumcision is nothing' (Gal. vi. 15); the Thessalonians receive a parting injunction against the spirit of restlessness and disorder spreading among them (1 Thess. v. 14, 2 Thess. iii. 14). The Apostle therefore would naturally lay stress on this point here, intending, as he appears to have done, to bring his letter to a speedy close. See the note on iii. 2. ὀκνηρόν, 'irksome, tedious.' The word generally signifies 'dilatory, sluggish,' as in the LXX frequently; but here it is active, 'causing ὄκτος,' as in Soph. Œd. T. 834 ἡμῖν μέν, ἄναξ, ταῦτ' ὀκνηρά.
The synonymes μορφή and σχῆμα¹.
The word σχῆμα corresponds exactly in derivation, though but partially in meaning, to the old English 'haviour.' In its first sense it denotes the figure, shape, fashion, of a thing. Thence it gathers several derived meanings. It gets to signify, like the corresponding Latin 'habitus,' sometimes the dress or costume (as Aristoph. Eq. 1331 τεττιγοφόρας ἀρχαίῳ σχήματι λαμπρός), sometimes the attitude or demeanour (as Eur. Ion 238 τρόπων τεκμήριον τὸ σχῆμ' ἔχεις τόδε). It is used also for a 'figure of speech,' as the dress in which the sense clothes itself or the posture which the language assumes. It signifies moreover pomp, display, outward circumstance (as Soph. Ant. 1169 τύραννον σχῆμ' ἔχων), and frequently semblance, pretence, as opposed to reality, truth (as Plat. Epin. p. 989 σοῦ σχήμασι τεχνάζοντας ἀλλὰ δληθεία τιμῶντας ἀρετήν, Plut. Vit. Galb. 15 ἀρνήσεως σχῆμα τὴν ἀναβολὴν εἶναι φάσκοντες, Eur. Fragm. Æol. 18 οὐδὲν ἄλλο πλὴν ὄχλος καὶ σχῆμα). Altogether it suggests the idea of something changeable, fleeting, unsubstantial.
Μορφή, like σχῆμα, originally refers to the organs of sense². If σχῆμα may be rendered by 'figure,' 'fashion,' μορφή corresponds to 'form.' It comprises all those sensible qualities, which striking the eye lead to the conviction that we see such and such a thing. The conviction indeed may be false, for the form may be a phantom; but to the senses at all events the representation of the object conceived is complete. The word has not and cannot have any of those secondary senses which attach to σχῆμα, as gesture or dress or parade or pretext. In many cases indeed the words are used convertibly, because the sense is sufficiently lax to include either. But the difference between the two is tested by the fact that the μορφή of a definite thing as such, for instance of a lion or a tree, is one only, while its σχῆμα may change every minute. Thus we often find μορφῆς σχῆμα, as in Latin 'figura formae'³, but rarely, if ever, σχήματος μορφή (Eur. Iph. Taur. 292 οὐ ταῦτά μορφῆς σχήματα, Ion 992 ποῖόν τι μορφῆς σχῆμα;). The σχῆμα is often an accident of the μορφή.
¹ The following note is founded on some remarks which appeared several years ago (in the Journal of Class. and Sacr. Philol. no. VII. p. 113 sq., 121), enlarged and modified. The distinction of μορφή and σχῆμα has since been drawn out by Archbishop Trench (N. T. Syn. § lxx) in his pointed and instructive manner.
² I have purposely avoided the question of its derivation, feeling that I have no right to an opinion on the subject. Benfey, Wurzel-lez. II. p. 309, connects it with the Sanscrit 'varpas,' 'form.'
³ As e. g. Lucr. iv. 69 'formai servare figuram.' Compare the account of 'forma' and 'figura' given by Döderlein, Lat. Syn. III. p. 25 sq. (referred to by Trench, l. c. p. 93). His distinction corresponds to that which is here given of μορφή and σχῆμα. 'The form (Gestalt),' he says, 'so far as it has definite outlines is figura; so far as it is the visible impression and the stamp of the inner being and corresponds thereto, it is forma.'
Its philosophical meaning.
Plato.
Aristotle.
From the primary popular sense of μορφή we pass to its secondary philosophical meaning. And here the older philosophers do not render much assistance. In Parmenides indeed (μορφὰς γὰρ κατίθεντο δύο, ver. 112 Karsten) the word signifies 'natures,' 'essences,' for he is speaking of two elemental principles of the universe. But without the light thrown upon its use here by the phraseology of later thinkers, no inference could safely be drawn from this solitary instance. In Plato we first meet with a clear example of its philosophical sense. In the Phædo (p. 103 E, 104 A) Socrates, eliciting the doctrine of ideas by question and answer after his wont, concludes that 'not only is the same name always claimed for the eἶδος¹ itself, but also for something else which is not the εἶδος and yet has its μορφή always whenever it exists.' And in illustration of his meaning he adduces the example of the odd and the number three, the latter being always called odd and being inseparable from oddness, though not the odd itself. Thus in Plato's language the μορφή is the impress of the idea on the individual, or in other words the specific character. It need not therefore denote any material sensible quality, as in the instance quoted it does not. In Plato however the philosophical sense of μορφή is very rare. On the other hand Aristotle uses it commonly. But its relation to εἶδος has undergone a change, corresponding to the difference in his metaphysical views. As he discards Plato's doctrine of ideas wholly, as he recognises no eternal selfexistent archetype distinct from the specific character exhibited in the individuals, it follows as a matter of course that with him εἶδος and μορφή are identical. There are, according to his teaching, two elements or principles or causes of things; the matter, the substratum supporting the qualities, and the form, the aggregate of the qualities². The form he calls indifferently εἶδος or μορφή³. He moreover designates it by various synonyms. It is sometimes 'the abstract conception realised' (τὸ τί ἦν εἶναι⁴), sometimes 'the essence corresponding to the definition' (ἡ οὐσία ἢ κατὰ τὸν λόγον), ¹ Here the εἶδος is plainly the ἰδέα.
Plato seems to have used both words alike to denote the eternal archetype, as for instance in the passages in Trendelenburg, Platon. de ideis doctr. p. 33 sqq. Where however especial accuracy was aimed at, ἰδέα would naturally be preferred to εἶδος: see Thompson's note on Archer Butler's Lectures II. p.
128.
² A large number of passages is collected by Waitz, Organon II. p. 401 sq. See also Heyder Aristot. u. Hegel. Dialektik p. 182 sq., and especially
Ritter and Preller Hist. Phil. p. 324 sq. (ed. 2). In other places Aristotle speaks of four causes, the efficient, the material, the formal, and the final. The final and the efficient causes however may be conceived as involved in the formal: see esp. G. Schneider, De Causa
Finali Aristotelea (Berol. 1865), p. 15 sq.
³ See Waitz Organon II. p. 405.
There are exceptional cases where either word is used in its popular rather than its philosophical sense, referring directly to the organs of vision: but Biese, die
Philosophie des Aristoteles I. p. 439, is not justified in his general distinction that μορφή is 'die äusserliche sichtbare
Form der Dinge,' and εἶδος 'das die
Dinge von innen heraus Gestaltende.'
This distinction may suit one passage, but it is contradicted by twenty others.
The same remark applies to the attempts made by the old commentators on Aristotle to distinguish μορφή and εἶδος.
⁴ On this term see Trendelenburg,
Rhein. Mus. II. p. 457 sq., esp. pp.
469, 481 (1828); comp. his note on de
Anima I. 1, 2, p. 192 sq.
sometimes 'the definition of the essence' (ὁ λόγος τῆς οὐσίας), sometimes 'the definition alone, sometimes 'the essence' alone. He calls it also 'the actuality' (ἐνέργεια) or 'the perfection' (ἐντελέχεια)¹, matter being designated 'the potentiality' (δύναμις). 'So rich in wealth and titles,' said a later writer of a rival school half in irony, 'is the εἶδος with Aristotle².' The significance of his μορφή or εἶδος will appear also from the fact that he elsewhere identifies it with the final cause (τέλος or οὗ ἕνεκα)³, because the end or purpose is implicitly contained in the qualities. It is still more evident from the intimate connexion which he conceives to exist between the form and the nature. 'The term nature,' he says, 'is used to signify three things; sometimes it is equivalent to the matter, sometimes to the form, sometimes to both combined. Of the nature according to matter and the nature according to form, the latter is the more influential (κυριωτέρα)⁴,' i.e. it has a more important function in making the thing what it is.
It will appear moreover from this account, that the term μορφή, though originally derived from the organs of sense like εἶδος, and referring to external conformation, has in the language of Aristotle a much wider application, being not only applied to physical qualities generally, but also extended to immaterial objects. Thus he says in one passage that skin, vein, membrane, and all such things, belong to the same μορφή⁵; in another, that courage and justice and prudence have the same μορφή in a state as in an individual⁶; in a third, that science and health may be called the μορφή and εἶδος of the scientific and the healthy respectively⁷; while in a fourth, criticising the saying of Democritus that 'anybody could see what was the form (μορφή) of a man,' meaning that he might be known by his shape and colour, he replies that 'a corpse has the form (μορφή) of the human shape (σχήματος) and yet nevertheless is not a man⁸.' The form of a man therefore in Aristotle's conception was something more than his sensible appearance.
This sense of μορφή, as the specific character, was naturally transmitted from these great original thinkers to the philosophers of later ages. It is philosophers found for instance in Plutarch⁹. It appears very definitely in the Neopla-
¹ On the form regarded as the ἐνέργεια and the ἐντελέχεια see Trendelenburg de Anima ii. 1, p. 295 sq.
² A Platonist in Stobæus Ecl. i. c. 13 οὕτως αὐτῷ πλούσιόν τε καὶ πολυώνυμόν ἐστι τὸ εἶδος.
³ See Schneider de Caus. Fin. Aristot. p. 10 sq. and the passages quoted p. 12.
⁴ Phys. Ausc. ii. 1, p. 192 A (Bekker), de Part. An. i. 1, p. 640 B. See below, note 8.
⁵ de Anim. Gen. ii. 3, p. 737 B.
⁶ Polit. vii. 1, p. 1323 B.
⁷ de Anima ii. 2, p. 414 A.
⁸ de Part. An. i. 1, p. 640 B, ἡ γὰρ κατὰ τὴν μορφὴν φύσις κυριωτέρα τῆς ὑλικῆς φύσεως. εἰ μὲν οὖν τῷ σχήματι καὶ τῷ χρώματι ἕκαστόν ἐστι τῶν τε ῥῷων καὶ τῶν μορίων, ὀρθῶς ἂν Δημόκριτος λέγοι· φαίνεται γὰρ οὕτως ὑπολαβεῖν. φησὶ γοῦν παντὶ δῆλον εἶναι οἷόν τι τὴν μορφὴν ἐστιν ὁ ἄνθρωπος, ὡς ὄντος αὐτοῦ τῷ τε σχήματι καὶ τῷ χρώματι γνωρίμου. καίτοι καὶ ὁ τεθνεὼς ἔχει τὴν αὐτὴν τοῦ σχήματος μορφήν, ἀλλ' ὅμως οὐκ ἔστιν ἄνθρωπος (i. c. the corpse has the μορφή of the human σχήμα, but it has not the μορφή of a man).
⁹ Mor. p. 1013 O αὐτὸς τε γὰρ ὁ κόσμος οὗτος καὶ τῶν μερῶν ἕκαστον αὐτοῦ συνέστηκεν ἐκ τε σωματικῆς οὐσίας καὶ νοητῆς, ὡν ἡ μὲν ὕλην καὶ ὑποκείμενον, ἡ δὲ μορφὴν καὶ εἶδος τῷ γενομένῳ παρέσχε κ.τ.λ. Comp. p. 1022 z. For these references and the passage in the
PHIL.
tonists¹. And what is more to our purpose, it is recognised by Philo, the chief representative of Alexandrian Judaism².
Popular language.
Nor can it have been wholly without influence on the language of every-day life. Terms, like ideas, gradually permeate society till they reach its lower strata. Words stamped in the mint of the philosopher pass into general currency, losing their sharpness of outline meanwhile, but in the main retaining their impress and value. The exclusive technicalities of the scholastic logic are the common property of shopmen and artisans in our own day.
New
Testament usage
Do we then find in the New Testament any distinction between μορφή and σχῆμα, corresponding to that which appears to have held roughly in the common language of the Greeks and to have been still further developed in the technical systems of philosophers?
of σχῆμα
A review of the passages where σχῆμα and its derivatives are used will not, I think, leave any doubt on the mind that this word retains the notion of 'instability, changeableness,' quite as strongly as in classical Greek. Thus 'the fashion of this world,' which 'passeth away,' is τὸ σχῆμα τοῦ κόσμου τούτου (1 Cor. vii. 31). 'To fall in with the fashion of this world' is συναχηματίζεσθαι τῷ αἰῶνι τούτῳ (Rom. xii. 2). 'To follow the capricious guidance of the passions' is συναχηματίζεσθαι ταῖς ἐπιθυμίαις (1 Pet. i. 14). The fictitious illusory transformation whereby evil assumes the mask of good—the false apostles appearing as the true, the prince of darkness as an angel of light, the ministers of Satan as ministers of righteousness—is described by the thrice repeated word μετασχηματίζεσθαι (2 Cor. xi. 13, 14, 15). The significance of σχῆμα will be felt at once, if in any of these passages we attempt to substitute μορφή in its stead³.
and μορφή.
On the other hand the great and entire change of the inner life, otherwise described as being born again, being created anew, is spoken of as a conversion of μορφή always, of σχῆμα never. Thus 'He fore-ordained them conformable (συμμόρφους) to the image of His Son' (Rom. viii. 29); 'Being made conformable (συμμορφιζόμενος) to His death' (Phil. iii. 10); 'We are transformed (μεταμορφούμεθα) into the same image' (2 Cor. iii. 18); 'To be transformed by the renewal of the mind' (Rom. xii. 2); 'Until Christ be formed (μορφωθῇ) in you' (Gal. iv. 19). In these passages again, if any one doubts whether μορφή has any special force, let him substitute σχῆμα and try the effect. In some cases indeed, where the organs of sense are concerned and where the appeal lies to popular usage, either word might be used. Yet I think it will be felt at once that in the account of the transfiguration μεταnext note I am indebted to Wyttenbach's note on Plato, Phæd. p. 103 E.
¹ See e.g. Plotin. Ennead. i. 6, p. 52 A, especially the expression οὐκ ἀνασχομένης τῆς ὕλης τὸ πάντη κατὰ τὸ εἶδος μορφοῦσθαι.
² de Vict. Off. § 13, p. 261 M, τὸ τεθλασμένον ἀφήρηται τὴν ποιότητα καὶ τὸ εἶδος καὶ οὐδὲν ἑτερὸν ἐστιν ἢ κυρίως εἰπεῖν ἄμορφος ὕλη, and lower down, ταῖς ἀσωμάτοις δυνάμεσιν, ὧν ἔτυμον ὄνομα αἱ ἰδέαι, κατεχρήσατο πρὸς τὸ γένος ἕκαστον τὴν ἁρμόττουσαν λαβεῖν μορφήν. For other references see Dähne Jüdisch-Alex. Religionsphilosophie 1. p. 185.
³ In 1 Cor. iv. 6 ταῦτα μετεσχημάτισα εἰς ἑμαυτὸν κ.τ.λ. the word refers to a rhetorical σχῆμα, and here μετεμόρφωσα would of course be out of place.
σχηματίζεσθαι would have been out of place and that μεταμορφοῦσθαι alone is adequate to express the completeness and significance of the change (Matt. xvii. 2, Mark ix. 2). Even in the later addition to St Mark's Gospel where our Lord is described as appearing to the two disciples ἐν ἑτέρᾳ μορφῇ, though μορφὴ here has no peculiar force, yet σχῆμα would perhaps be avoided instinctively, as it might imply an illusion or an imposture. It will be observed also that in two passages where St Paul speaks of an appearance which is superficial and unreal, though not using σχῆμα, he still avoids μορφὴ as inappropriate and adopts μόρφωσις instead (Rom. ii. 20 τὴν μόρφωσιν τῆς γνώσεως καὶ τῆς ἀληθείας, 2 Tim. iii. 5 μόρφωσιν εὐσεβείας). Here the termination denotes the aiming after or affecting the μορφή.
And the distinction, which has thus appeared from the review of each Concur- word separately, will be seen still more clearly from those passages where they rence of occur together. In Rom. xii. 2 μὴ συνσχηματίζεσθαι τῷ αἰὼν τούτῳ the two ἀλλὰ μεταμορφοῦσθαι τῇ ἀνακοινώσει τοῦ νοῦς. the form of the sentence calls attention to the contrast, and the appropriateness of each word in its own connexion is obvious: 'Not to follow the fleeting fashion of this world, but to undergo a complete change, assume a new form, in the renewal of the mind.' On the other hand in Phil. iii. 21 μετασχηματίσει τὸ σῶμα τῆς τα- πεινώσεως ἡμῶν σύμμορφον τῷ σώματι τῆς δόξης αὐτοῦ, the difference is not obvious at first sight. The meaning however seems to be, 'will change the fashion of the body of our humiliation and fix it in the form of the body of His glory.' Here I think it will be clear that a compound of σχῆμα could not be substituted for σύμμορφον without serious detriment to the sense: while on the other hand μεταμορφώσει might possibly have stood for μετασχηματίσει¹.
I now come to the passage in the Epistle to the Philippians out of Phil. ii. 6, which this investigation has arisen. But before attempting to discover 7- what is implied by μορφὴ Θεοῦ, it will be necessary to clear the way by dis- posing of a preliminary question. Does the expression ἐν μορφῇ Θεοῦ ὑπάρχων refer to the pre-incarnate or the incarnate Christ? Those who The pre- adopt the latter view for the most part explain the words of the super- incarnate natural or divine power and grace manifested by our Lord during His Christ is earthly ministry. Thus in ancient times the Ambrosian Hilary, 'Deus meant, apparet, dum mortuos excitat, surdis reddit auditum, leprosos mundat, et alia': thus in a later age Erasmus, 'Ipsis factis se Deum esse declara- ret etc.'; and Luther, 'Dass göttliche Gestalt nichts anderes sei denn sich erzeigen mit Worten und Werken gegen andere als ein Herr und Gott².' Against this view De Wette, though himself referring the ex- pression to Christ incarnate, urges with justice that the point of time marked by ὑπάρχων is evidently prior to our Lord's actual ministry,
¹ Of the two words μετασχηματίζειν would refer to the transient condition from which, μεταμορφοῦν to the perma- nent state to which, the change takes place. Archbishop Trench however sup- poses that μετασχηματίζειν is here pre- ferred to μεταμορφοῦν as expressing
'transition but no absolute solution of continuity,' the spiritual body being developed from the natural, as the butterfly from the caterpillar; N. T. Syn. 2nd ser. p. 91.
² Postill. ad. Epist. Domin. Palm. (xii. p. 630 ed. Hall.), quoted by De Wette.
9-2 the period of this ministry itself being a period of humiliation. He therefore explains it as describing the glory dwelling potentially in Christ, at the moment when He commenced His ministry. The meaning of St Paul, he thinks, is best illustrated by the account of the temptation (Matt. iv. 8), where our Lord rejects Satan's offer of 'all the kingdoms of the world and their glory.' At that moment and in that act of renunciation it might be said of Him that ἐν μορφῇ Θεοῦ ὑπάρχων οὐχ ἁρπαγμὸν ἡγήσατο τὸ εἶναι ἴσα Θεῷ ἀλλὰ ἑαυτὸν ἐκένωσιν. But this is quite as unsatisfactory as the explanation which he rejects. The point of time is clearly prior not only to our Lord's open ministry, but also to His becoming man. Even if the words μορφὴν δούλου λαβών did not directly refer to the incarnation, as they appear to do, nothing else can be understood by ἐν ὁμοιώματι ἀνθρώπων γενόμενος. We cannot suppose St Paul to have meant, that our Lord was not in the likeness of men before His baptism and ministry, and became so then for the first time. On the contrary all accounts alike agree in representing this (so far as regards His earthly life) as the turning-point when He began to 'manifest forth His glory' (John ii. 11).' It was an exaggeration indeed when certain early heretics represented His baptism as the moment of His first assumption of Deity: but only by a direct reversal of the accounts in the Gospel could it be regarded in any sense as the commencement of His humanity. The whole context in St Paul clearly implies that the being born as man was the first step in His humiliation, as the death on the Cross was the last. In other words, it requires that ἐν μορφῇ Θεοῦ ὑπάρχων be referred to a point of time prior to the incarnation.
Thus
μορφή
refers to the divine attributes.
This being so, what meaning must we attach to 'the form of God' in which our Lord pre-existed? In the Clementine Homilies St Peter is represented as insisting upon the anthropomorphic passages in the Scriptures and maintaining therefrom that God has a sensible form (μορφή). To the objection of his opponent that if God has a form (μορφή), He must have a figure, a shape (σχῆμα) also, the Apostle is made to reply by accepting the inference: 'God has a σχῆμα; He has eyes and hands and feet like a man; nevertheless He has no need to use them'. Not such was St Paul's conception of God. Not in this sense could he speak of the μορφή, not in any sense could he speak of the σχῆμα, of Him who is 'King of kings and Lord of lords, who only hath immortality, who dwelleth in light unapproachable, whom no man hath seen or can see' (1 Tim. vi. 15, 16).' It remains then that μορφή must apply to the attributes of the Godhead. In other words, it is used in a sense substantially the same which it bears in Greek philosophy². It suggests the same idea which is otherwise expressed in
¹ Clem. Hom. xvii. 3, 7, 8.
² A passage in Justin Martyr (Apol. i. 9) fairly illustrates the distinction of μορφή and σχῆμα in St Paul. He says that Christians do not believe the idols formed by men's hands to have the form (μορφήν) of God; they have only the names and the shapes (σχήματα) of demons; the form of God is not of this kind (οὐ τοιαύτην ἔχειν τὴν μορφήν); His glory and form are ineffable (ἀρρητον δόξαν καὶ μορφὴν ἔχων). He thus appears to contrast the visible σχήματα of demons with the insensible immaterial μορφή of God. A corresponding distinction also seems to hold in the Pistis
St John by ὁ Λόγος τοῦ Θεοῦ, in Christian writers of succeeding ages by
νίος Θεοῦ ὦν Θεός, and in the Nicene Creed by Θεὸς ἐκ Θεοῦ.
In accepting this conclusion we need not assume that St Paul consciously derived his use of the term from any philosophical nomenclature. There was sufficient definiteness even in its popular usage to suggest this meaning when it was transferred from the objects of sense to the conceptions of the mind. Yet if St John adopted λόγος, if St Paul himself adopted εἰκών, πρωτοτοκος, and the like, from the language of existing theological schools, it seems very far from improbable that the closely analogous expression μορφὴ Θεοῦ should have been derived from a similar source. The speculations of Alexandrian and Gnostic Judaism formed a ready channel, by which the philosophical terms of ancient Greece were brought within reach of the Apostles of Christ.
Thus in the passage under consideration the μορφὴ is contrasted with the σχήμα, as that which is intrinsic and essential with that which is accidental and outward. And the three clauses imply respectively the true divine nature of our Lord (μορφὴ Θεοῦ), the true human nature (μορφὴ δοῦλου), and the externals of the human nature (σχήματι ὡς ἄνθρωπος)¹.
Different interpretations of οὐχ ἁρπαγμὸν ἡγήσατο.
It will appear from the notes, that two principal interpretations of οὐχ ἀρπαγμὸν ἡγήσατο have been proposed, depending on the different senses assigned to ἁρπαγμός. In the one the prominent idea is the assertion, in the other the surrender, of privileges. The one lays stress on the majesty, the other on the humility, of our Lord. These two interpretations may conveniently be considered side by side and discussed at greater length.
1. If ἁρπαγμός 'plundering' is taken to mean 'robbery,' 'usurpation,' then the expression asserts that the equality with God was the natural possession, the inherent right, of our Lord. This interpretation suits the
Sophia, where both words occur several times, pp. 38, 184, 226, 246, 253, 272, 273, 274, 277; the former especially in the phrase ἀλήθεια μορφῆς opposed to similitude or copy (παράδειγμα, see p. 253), the latter in connexion with τύποι and παραδείγματα (see esp. 272 sq.).
¹ In the controversies of the fourth and fifth centuries great stress was laid by Catholic writers on the force of μορφή here. See for instance Hilary of Poitiers de Trin. viii. 45 (II. p. 245), Psalm cxxxviii. (I. p. 569), Ambrose Epist. 46 (II. p. 986), Greg. Nyss. c. Eunom. iv. p. 566 (ἡ δὲ μορφὴ τοῦ Θεοῦ ταὐτὸν τῇ οὐσίᾳ πάντων ἐστιν), and the commentators Victorinus, Ambrosiaster, Chrysostom, and Theodoret, on this passage. St Chrysostom especially discusses the matter at some length. It is not surprising that they should have taken this view, but they could hardly have insisted with such confidence on the identity of μορφή and οὐσία, unless they had at least a reasonable case on their side. I trust the investigation in the text will show that their view was not groundless, though their language might be at times overstrained.
The context lost sight of.
words themselves well enough, when isolated from their context, and so far is free from objection. But it takes no account of the clauses which immediately precede and follow. (1) It neglects the foregoing words. For the Apostle is there enforcing the duty of humility, and when he adds 'Have the mind which was in Jesus Christ,' we expect this appeal to our great Example to be followed immediately by a reference, not to the right which He claimed, but to the dignity which He renounced. The dislocation of thought caused by this interpretation is apparent; 'Be ye humble and like-minded with Christ, who partaking of the divine nature claimed equality with God.' The mention of our Lord's condescension is thus postponed too late in the sentence. (2) And again this interpretation wholly disregards the connexion with the words following. For in the expression οὐχ ἁρπαγμὸν ἡγήσατο κ.τ.λ. ἀλλὰ ἑαυτὸν ἐκίνωσεν, the particles οὐχ and ἀλλὰ obviously correspond, 'not the one but the other'; so that ἐκίνωσεν ἑαυτὸν must contain the idea which directly contrasts with ἁρπαγμὸν ἡγήσατο. On the other hand the interpretation in question renders ἀλλὰ as equivalent to ἀλλ' ὅμως. Besides being unnatural in itself after οὐχ, this rendering fails entirely to explain the emphatic position of ἁρπαγμόν.
Influence of the
Latin fathers.
This sense, which is adopted in our own English Version and has been extensively received in modern times, may probably be traced to the influence of the Latin fathers, who interpreted the rendering of the Latin Version without reference to the original. The Latin phrase 'rapinam arbitrari' did not convey the secondary meaning which was at once suggested by ἁρπαγμὸν (ἁρπαγμα) ἡγείσθαι; nor perhaps would the Latin particles 'non...sed' bring out the idea of contrast so strongly as οὐχ...ἀλλὰ. At all events it should be noticed, that while this interpretation is most common (though not universal) among Latin writers, it is unsupported by a single Greek father, unless possibly at a very late date.
Such is the interpretation of TERTULLIAN de Resurr. Carn. 6, adv. Prax. 7, adv. Marc. v. 20; of the AMBROSIAN HILARY here; of ST AMBROSE de Fid. ii. 8 (IL p. 483 ed. Bened.) 'Quod enim quis non habet, rapere conatur; ergo non quasi rapinam habebat æqualitatem cum Patre etc.'; of PRIMASIUS here; and above all of ST AUGUSTINE who again and again quotes and explains the passage in his Sermons, 92 (v. p. 500 ed. Bened.), 118 (p. 587), 183 (p. 875), 186 (p. 885), 213 (p. 937), 244 (p. 1019), 264 (p. 1075), 292 (p. 1170), 304 (p. 1235); comp. in Psalm. xc (IV. p. 972). The distinctness with which this interpretation was enunciated by the greatest teacher of the Western Church would necessarily secure for it a wide reception.
(2) ἁρπαγμός
'a prize.'
2. If on the other hand ἁρπαγμὸν ἡγείσθαι is considered equivalent to the common phrase ἁρπαγμα ἡγείσθαι, so that ἁρπαγμός will signify 'a prize,' 'a treasure,' then the logical connexion with the context before and after is strictly preserved: 'Be humble as Christ was humble: He, though existing before the worlds in the form of God, did not treat His equality with God as a prize, a treasure to be greedily clutched and ostentatiously displayed: on the contrary He resigned the glories of heaven.' The only objection to this rendering, the form ἁρπαγμός in place of ἁρπαγμα, has been considered in the notes.
This is the common and indeed almost universal interpretation of the Greek fathers, who would have the most lively sense of the requirements of the language. So it is evidently taken in the earliest passage where it is quoted, in the Epistle of the CHURCHES OF GAUL (Euseb. II. E. v. 2), where praising the humility of the martyrs they say ἐπὶ τοσεύτου ζηλωταὶ καὶ μιμηταὶ Χριστοῦ ἐγένοντο, ὃς ἐν μορφῇ Θεοῦ ὑπάρχων οὐχ ἁρπαγμὸν ἠγήσατο τὸ εἶναι ἴσα Θεῷ, evidently thinking this clause to contain in itself a statement of His condescension. So ORIGEN clearly takes it; in Joann. VI. § 37 (IV. p. 156 D) μέχρι θανάτου καταβαίνειν ὑπὲρ ἀσεβῶν, οὐχ ἁρπαγμὸν ἠγούμενον τὸ εἶναι ἴσα Θεῷ, καὶ κενοῦν ἑαυτὸν κ.τ.λ.; in Matth. Comm. Ser. (III. p. 916 C) 'Vere Jesus non rapinam arbitratus est esse se æqualem Deo, et non semel sed frequenter pro omnibus seipsum humiliavit'; in Rom. v. § 2 (IV. p. 553 A) 'Nec rapinam ducit esse se æqualem Deo, hoc est, non sibi magni aliquid deputat quod ipse quidem æqualis Deo et unum cum patre sit'; ib. x. § 7 (IV. p. 672 C) 'Christus non sibi placens nec rapinam arbitrans esse se æqualem Deo semetipsum exinanivit.' So too METHODIUS; Methodius. Fragm. p. 105 (Jahn) αὐτὸς ὁ Κύριος, ὁ υἱὸς τοῦ Θεοῦ, τιμῶν αὐτὸ [τὸ μαρτύριον] ἐμαρτύρησεν, οὐχ ἁρπαγμὸν ἠγησάμενος τὸ εἶναι ἴσα Θεῷ, ἵνα καὶ τούτῳ τὸν ἄνθρωπον τῷ χαρίσματι εἰς ὃν κατέβη στέψῃ. So again EUSEDIUS Eusebius. unmistakeably; Eccl. Proph. iii. 4 ἐγενήθη πένης, οὐχ ἁρπαγμὸν ἠγούμενος τὸ εἶναι ἴσα Θεῷ ἀλλ' ἑαυτὸν ταπεινῶν κ.τ.λ.; Eccles. Theol. i. 13 (p. 57) προϋπάρχων, θεότητι πωρικῆς δόξης τετιμημένος· οὐ μὴν ἁρπαγμὸν ἠγούμενος τὸ εἶναι ἴσα Θεῷ ἑαυτὸν δ' οὖν κενώσας κ.τ.λ.; comp. ib. i. 20 (p. 94). So also THEODORE OF MOFSUESTIA (Raban. Maur. Op. VI. p. 488 B ed. Migne) Theodore. 'Non magnam reputavit illam quæ ad Deum est æqualitatem et elatus in sua permansit dignitate, sed magis pro aliorum utilitate præelegit humiliora etc.'; and after him THEODORET, interpreting the passage, τὴν πρὸς τὸν πατέρα ἰσότητα ἔχων οὐ μίγα τοῦτο ὑπέλαβε. So moreover the PSEUDO-ATHANASIUS Hom. de Sem. (Athan. Op. II. p. 49 ed. Bened.) χρισθεὶς δὲ ὁ Δαυειδ εἰς βασιλεία οὐχ ἅμα ἥρπασε τὴν βασιλείαν ἀλλ' ἠνείχετο πολλοῖς χρόνοις δουλεύων τῷ Σαούλ' καὶ ὁ σωτὴρ ἡμῶν γεννηθεὶς βασιλεὺς πρὸ τῶν αἰώνων...ἠνείχετο, οὐχ ἁρπαγμὸν ἠγήσατο τὸ εἶναι ἴσα Θεῷ κ.τ.λ. So in like manner ISIDORE OF PELUSIUM Epist. iv. 22 εἰ ἔρμαιον ἠγήσατο τὸ εἶναι ἴσον οὐκ ἂν ἑαυτὸν ἐταπείνωσεν...δοῦλος μὲν γὰρ καὶ ἐλευθερωθεὶς καὶ υἱοθεσίᾳ τιμηθεὶς ἄτε ἁρπαγμα ἢ εὕρημα τὴν ἀξίαν ἠγησάμενος οὐδ' ἂν ὑποσταίῃ οἰκενικὸν ἔργον ἀνύσαι' ὁ δὲ γνήσιος υἱὸς κ.τ.λ.; and CYRIL OF ALEXANDRIA c. Jul. vi (VI. p. 195 ed. Aubert.) ὁ μὲν γὰρ τῶν ὅλων σωτὴρ καὶ Κύριος, καίτοι μετὸν αὐτῷ τὸ ἐν μορφῇ καὶ ἰσότητι τῇ κατὰ πᾶν ὁτιοῦν ὁρᾶσθαι πρὸς τὸν πατέρα καὶ τοῖς τῆς θεότητος ἐναβρύνεσθαι θάκοις, οὐχ ἁρπαγμὸν ἠγήσατο κ.τ.λ. (where the καίτοι is decisive). In addition to this positive testimony it should be noticed, that throughout the important controversies of the fourth and fifth centuries it does not seem once to have occurred to any Greek father to put forward the other explanation of the passage, though so eminently favourable to the orthodox belief¹.
¹ It is not clear what interpretation was adopted by Didymus of Alexandria de Trin. i. 26 (p. 73). Τί τῆς ἰσότητος ταύτης εὑρίσκεται ἄνισον; οὐχ
ἥρπασε γάρ, φησίν, οὐκ ἔλαβε τὸ ἴσον εἶναι τῇ φύσει τῷ Θεῷ καὶ πατρὶ· καὶ δὴ ὁ μὴ ὑπ' ἄλλου κενωθεὶς ἑαυτὸν δὲ κενώσας αὐθέντην δεσπότην ὁμοῦ καὶ
Also by Hilary and Jerome.
The two senses compared.
A middle course taken by Chrysostom.
Objection to his explanation.
Nor is the interpretation thus generally adopted by Greek writers confined to them alone. Some of the most acute and learned of the Latin fathers explain it in the same way.
Thus perhaps HILARY OF POITIERS de Trin. viii. 45 (II. p. 246 ed. Bened.) 'Non sibi rapiens esse se æqualem Deo, ad susceptionem se formas servilis per obedientiam exinanivit...non tamen æqualem se Deo per rapinam existimans quamvis in forma Dei et æqualis Deo per Deum Deus signatus exstaret¹'; and more clearly JEROME ad Hedib. Q. 9 (Epist. 120, I. p. 837) 'Pro quibus non rapinam arbitratus est se esse æqualem Deo sed semetipsum exinanivit'; see also his notes on Gal. iv. 12, v. 14³.
In comparing these two interpretations, it will be seen that while the former makes οὐχ ἁρπαγμὸν ἡγήσατο a continuation and expansion of the idea already contained in ἐν μορφῇ Θεοῦ ὑπάρχων, 'He existed in the form of God and so did not think it usurpation to be equal with God'; the latter treats the words as involving a contrast to this idea, 'He existed in the form of God but nevertheless did not eagerly assert His equality with God.' In short the two interpretations of the clause, as I have said before, are directly opposed, inasmuch as the one expresses our Lord's assertion, the other His cession, of the rights pertaining to His divine majesty.
And between these two explanations—the one which interprets ἁρπαγμὸν by ἀδικίαν, and the other which interprets it by ἔρμαιον—our choice must be made. A middle interpretation however was maintained by St Chrysostom, and has been adopted with more or less distinctness by others, especially in recent times. It agrees very nearly with the first in the sense assigned to ἁρπαγμός, and yet approaches to the second in the general drift of the clause. 'Being in the form of God, He did not consider that He was plundering, when He claimed equality with God. He did not therefore look upon His divine prerogatives as a booty of which He feared to be deprived and which therefore it was necessary to guard jealously. He reigned not as a tyrant but as a lawful sovereign. He could therefore divest himself of the outward splendours of His rank without fear².'
As an indirect doctrinal inference from the passage, this account is admissible; but as a direct explanation of its bearing, it is faulty because it understands too much, requiring links to be supplied which the connexion does not suggest and which interrupt the sequence of thought.
ἀξίων ἑαυτὸν ἀπέδειξεν: comp. ib. iii. 17 (p. 377). The expression οὐχ ἥρπασε however seems to point to an intermediate interpretation like the one adopted by Chrysostom, as given in the text. Nothing can be inferred from the language of St Basil adv. Eunom. iv. (I. p. 294 F. 295 A), or from Liturg. S. Bas. p. 158 (Neale).
¹ Yet in another passage c. Const. Imper. § 19 (II. p. 577) he says, 'Non rapit quod erat Christus,' which points to the other sense of ἁρπαγμός. Perhaps he, like Chrysostom, adopted a middle interpretation combining features of both.
² This is probably the view also of Victorinus in his commentary on the passage, 'Ergo nunc Paulus, Non, inquit, Christus rapinam credidit, id est, hoc sibi vindicavit, tantum habere voluit ut forma Dei esset, sed etiam se ipsum exinanivit etc.'; but his language is not distinct. See again his treatise c. Aríum i. 9, Galland Bibl. Vet. Patr. VIII. p. 155.
³ Op. XI. p. 245. I have abridged his explanation.
All similar attempts to mediate between the two opposing explanations fail in the same way and tend only to confuse the interpretation of the passage.
Of the two explanations then, between which our choice lies, the context, as I have shown, seems imperatively to require the second; and if authority count for anything, the list of names, by which it is maintained, sufficiently refutes the charge of being 'liable to grave suspicion on theological grounds.' We should do wisely however to consider its doctrinal bearing, without reference to authority.
Now while the other explanation directly asserts our Lord's divinity, this confessedly does not. Yet on the other hand the theological difference is only apparent. For, though we miss the direct assertion in this particular clause, the doctrine still remains. It is involved in the preceding words, for the 'pre-existence in the form of God,' as will appear I think from the last note, means substantially this. It is indirectly implied moreover in this very clause taken in connexion with the context. For how could it be a sign of humility in our Lord not to assert His equality with God, if He were not divine? How could such a claim be considered otherwise than arrogant and blasphemous, if He were only a man? If St Chrysostom's interpretation must be rejected as faulty and confused, his argument at least is valid; 'No one wishing to exhort to humility says, Be humble and think less of yourself than of your compeers (Ἕλαττον φρόνει τῶν ὁμοτίμων), for such and such a person being a slave did not set himself up against his master; therefore imitate him. Nay, one might reply, here is a question not of humility, but of infatuation (ἀπονοίας)'; 'It is no humility for the inferior not to set himself up against his superior'; 'If being a man, He washed the feet of men, He did not empty, did not humble Himself; if being a man, He did not grasp at equality with God, He deserves no praise¹.'
One who refuses to claim some enviable privilege may be influenced by either of two motives, by a feeling of humility or by a sense of justice, according as he has or has not a right to this privilege. Those who hold humanitarian views of the Person of Christ necessarily take the latter view of the motive in this instance. The equality with God, they argue, was not asserted, because it would have been an act of usurpation to do so. To this view it may fairly be objected, that it overlooks the true significance of ἁρπαγμὸν (ἁρπαγμα) ἡγεῖσθαι, which as a recognised phrase is equivalent to ἔρμαιον ἡγεῖσθαι and therefore refers to the desirableness of the possession or acquisition. But its fatal condemnation is this, that it treats the clause as isolated and takes no account of the context. The act expressed by οὐχ ἁρπαγμὸν ἡγήσατο is brought forward as an example of humility, and can only be regarded as such, if the expression τὸ εἶναι ἴσα Θεῷ refers to rights which it was an act of condescension to waive².
Theological bearing of the interpretation adopted.
It does not favour humanitarian views.
¹ Op. xi. pp. 136, 237, 247.
² One other interpretation put forward by recent commentators deserves attention. Meyer (followed by Dean Alford), desirous of giving ἁρπαγμὸν the active sense which its termination suggests, translates the words, 'Did not look upon His being on an equality with God, as a means of self-enrichment.' In answer to the mechanical objection urged against this sense, that a state (τὸ εἶναι) cannot be regarded as an action (ἁρπαγμὸν), he justly appeals to 1 Tim. vi. 5 νομιζόντων πορισμὸν εἶναι
Lost Epistles to the Philippians?
Supposed reference to such in the Epistle itself and in
Polycarp.
Probabilities considered.
It has been maintained by some, that a passage in the Epistle to the Philippians implies a more or less sustained correspondence between St Paul and his converts, so that the extant letter is only a single link in a long chain. 'To write the same things,' says St Paul, 'to me is not irksome, while for you it is safe.' The reference, it is urged, cannot be explained from the epistle itself, since it does not supply any topic which satisfies the two conditions, of occurring in the immediate context, and of being repeated elsewhere in the course of the letter.
Moreover the inference thus suggested is thought to be confirmed by an allusion in the Epistle of Polycarp. Writing to these same Philippians, he says (§ 3); 'Neither I nor another like me can attain to the wisdom of the blessed and glorious Paul; who coming among you taught the word of truth accurately and surely before the men of that day; who also when absent wrote letters (ἐπιστολάς) to you, into which if ye search ye can be builded up unto the faith given to you.'
Against this view no objection can be taken from the probabilities of the case. On the contrary it is only reasonable to suppose, that during the ten or eleven years which elapsed between the epoch of their conversion and the date of this epistle, the Apostle, ever overflowing with love and ever prompt to seize the passing opportunity, would have written not once or twice only to converts with whom his relations were so close and affectionate. And—to consider the broader question—if we extend our range of view beyond the Philippians to the many churches of his founding, if we take into account not these ten years only but the whole period of his missionary life, we can hardly resist the conclusion that in the epistles of our Canon we have only a part—perhaps not a very large part—of the whole correspondence of the Apostle either with churches or with individuals.
But, if there be any reluctance to allow that the letter of an inspired Apostle could have been permitted to perish, a moment's thought will dissipate the scruple. Any theory of inspiration, which would be consistent with historical fact, must find a place for this supposition. It is true of Him who 'spake as never man spake,' that if all His words had been preserved, 'the world itself could not contain the books that should be written.' Yet His recorded sayings may be read through in a very few hours. And τὴν εὐσέβειαν, which presents an exact parallel in this respect. This interpretation suits the context very fairly, but it seems to me to be somewhat strained; and the fact that ἄρπαγμα ἡγεῖσθαι (ποιεῖσθαι) is a common phrase meaning 'to prize highly, to welcome eagerly,' and that ἄρπαγμόν ἡγεῖσθαι (ποιεῖσθαι), wherever else it occurs, has also this sense, would appear to be decisive. Meyer indeed attempts to force his own meaning on ἄρπαγμόν in the passage of Cyril, de Ador. i. p. 25, quoted above (in the notes, p. 111); but when this writer, speaking of Lot's renewal of the offer of hospitality when declined by the angels, describes this importunity by οὐχ ἄρπαγμόν τὴν παραίτησιν ἐποιεῖτο, it is difficult to conceive that the phrase can mean anything else but 'did not eagerly close with, did not gladly welcome their refusal.' on the ground of inspiration we cannot assuredly claim for the letters of the Apostle an immunity from the ravages of time, which was denied to the words of the Saviour Himself. The 'litera scripta' indeed has a firmer hold on life. But the difficulty of multiplying copies, the strife of parties within the Church, and the perils assailing the brotherhood from without, are sufficient to explain the loss of any documents in the earlier ages. And from the nature of the case the letters of the Apostles could not have been so highly prized by their contemporaries, as by later generations. History confirms the suggestion which reason makes, that the writings of the first teachers of the Gospel grew in importance, as the echo of their voice died away. A letter from a dear friend is a poor substitute for the free interchange of conversation. But when he is taken from us, we know not how to value his correspondence highly enough¹.
At all events indications are not wanting of other letters besides those which have been preserved for the instruction of the Church. The two short Epistles to the Thessalonians stand alone in a period which extends over at least twenty years before and after². Yet in one of these the Apostle calls attention to his mode of signature, as a guarantee of genuineness, which occurred 'in every epistle' written by him³. Such an expression would be conclusive, even if unsupported by other allusions, which suggest at least the suspicion that several letters may have passed between St Paul and his Thessalonian converts⁴. Again, his written communications with the Corinthians seem to have extended beyond the two extant epistles. In a passage in the First Epistle, according to the most probable interpretation, he directly alludes to a previous letter addressed to them⁵: and the acknowledgment of the Corinthians, which he elsewhere mentions, that his 'letters are weighty and powerful,' together with his own reply 'Such as we are by letters when absent etc.'⁶ cannot be ex-
¹ Prof. Jowett, Epistles of St Paul 1. p. 195 (2nd ed.), has an instructive essay on the probability of many epistles having been lost. With some of his special criticisms however I venture to disagree. He supposes for instance that 1 Cor. v. 9 refers to the First Epistle to the Corinthians itself, and that Col. iv. 16 does not refer to the Epistle to the Ephesians.
² Fourteen years at least, probably seventeen (see notes Gal. ii. 1), elapsed between St Paul's conversion and the third visit to Jerusalem (A.D. 51). The Epistles to the Corinthians, which probably follow next in order after the Epistles to the Thessalonians, were not written till A.D. 57, 58. Thus the whole period will be 20 or 23 years, according to the reckoning adopted.
³ 1 Thess. iii. 17.
⁴ 1 Thess. ii. 2, 15.
⁵ 1 Cor. v. 9 ἔγραψα ὑμῖν ἐν τῇ ἐπιστολῇ μὴ συναναυγνῶσαι πόρνοι. The real difficulty in referring this allusion to the First Epistle itself lies not in ἔγραψα, which might be explained as an epistolary acriot, but in ἐν τῇ ἐπιστολῇ 'in my letter,' which is thus rendered meaningless: see Journal of Class. and Sacr. Phil. ii. p. 196 (note). Two independent reasons have probably conspired to promote the unnatural explanation by which it is referred to the First Epistle. (1) On theological grounds commentators have been unwilling to admit that an epistle of St Paul could have perished: while (2) they have been misled critically by the context, ver. 11 νῦν δὲ ἔγραψα κ.τ.λ., taking νῦν in its primary temporal sense, whereas it appears to mean, 'under these circumstances,' 'the world being what it is.'
⁶ 2 Cor. A. 10, 11.
[Laodicea.]
plained quite satisfactorily (though the explanation might pass) by the single extant epistle written before this date. On the other hand the 'letter from Laodicea,' which the Apostle directs the Colossians to procure and read¹, must not be classed among these lost letters, as there is very good reason for supposing that he there refers to the circular letter to the Asiatic Churches, sent to Laodicea as one of the great centres and thence communicated to the neighbouring town of Colossæ, but circulated in the Church at large through the metropolis of Asia and therefore generally known as the Epistle to the Ephesians. Whether to these lost letters to Thessalonica and to Corinth we are required to add one or more addressed to the Philippians, I propose now to consider. The general question has only been introduced to prepare the way for this investigation.
Explanations of
Phil. iii. 1 examined.
1. The passage in the Epistle to the Philippians itself has been variously explained. Some have interpreted it 'to repeat in writing the same injunctions which I gave you myself by word of mouth,' or 'which I charged you by my messengers.' But such amplifications receive no encouragement from the words themselves, which mean simply 'to write the same things again and again.' To written communications therefore our attention must be confined.
Even with this limitation, three solutions are offered. Either (1) The extant epistle itself consists of two separate letters welded together; or (2) A lost letter must be assumed in which the same subject was introduced; or (3) The often repeated topic must be discovered in the extant letter. The first of these solutions has been already considered and set aside²; nor indeed does it contribute anything towards the interpretation of this passage (though it would explain the plural in Polycarp), for no new topic is introduced by the disintegration of the existing letter. The second might very fairly be accepted in default of a better: but there is nothing in the words which suggests a reference to any incident external to the letter itself, and it is therefore simpler not to look elsewhere for the allusion. The third view then seems preferable, if any topic can be found which satisfies the conditions. And in the notes on the passage I have attempted to show that such a topic is not wanting.
Allusion in
Polycarp considered.
2. But the reference in the Epistle of Polycarp still remains to be explained. What account must be given of the 'letters,' which St Paul wrote to the Philippians? Does Polycarp, as some have thought, include the Thessalonian Epistles, which as being addressed to a neighbouring Church would be known and read at Philippi also? This is possible; but a simpler solution offers itself. Notwithstanding the plural ἐπιστολαί, the reference may be satisfied by the one extant Epistle to the Philippians. Of this usage of the plural ἐπιστολαί, applying to a single letter³, there can be no doubt. This will appear plainly from Thucyd. viii. 51 ὄσον οὐ παρούσαν ἀπὸ τοῦ Ἀλκιβιάδου περὶ τούτων ἐπιστολήν, compared with αἱ δὲ παρὰ τοῦ Ἀλκιβιάδου ἐπιστολαὶ οὐ πολὺ ὕστερον ἦκον; from Joseph. Ant. xii. 4. 10 ἐπιστολαί
used of a single letter.
¹ Col. iv. 16. I hope to consider the question of the 'epistle from Laodicea' in the introduction to the Epistle to the Ephesians: see also Colossians p. 274 sq.
² See the introduction, page 69 note.
³ Thom. Mag. p. 354 καὶ ἐπιστολὴ καὶ ἐπιστολαὶ πληθυντικῶς· ῥητορικόν.
ὁ Λακεδαιμονίων βασιλεὺς Ἄρειος πρεσβείων τε ἔπεμπε καὶ ἐπιστολάς ὡν τὸ ἀντίγραφόν ἐστι τοιοῦτον, compared with ἡ μὲν οὖν ἐπιστολὴ ἡ πεμφθεῖσα παρὰ τοῦ Λακεδαιμονίων βασιλέως τοῦτον περιείχε τὸν τρόπον¹: and from Alciphron Epist. ii. 4 ὡς διεπέμψω μου τοῦ βασιλέως τὰς ἐπιστολάς, εὐθὺς ἀνέγνων, compared with σοβοῦσα ταῖς χερσὶν ἑμαντῆς τὴν ἐπιστολὴν σὺν αὐτῇ τῇ βασιλικῇ σφραγίδι; the singular in each case standing in the immediate neighbourhood of the plural and referring to the same writing. I have placed these instances side by side, because the context in all three cases determines the sense, and because being taken from writers of different epochs they show that the usage was not confined to any one period. The following references also, which might be multiplied many times, serve to illustrate its occurrence in classical writers at different stages of the language: Eur. Iph. Taur. 589, 767, Iph. Aul. 111, 314, Thucyd. i. 132, iv. 50, Polyb. v. 43. 5, Lucian. Avar. 47 (II. p. 450), Julian. Epist. 73 (comp. Epist. 44)². Nor is this usage confined to classical Greek. In Esth. iii. 14 ἐπιστολαί is a translation of a singular substantive (כֹּהֵב); while in 1 Macc. v. 14, x. 3, 7, xi. 29, xii. 5 etc., it plainly refers to a single document. And in ecclesiastical writers of a later date examples are found. Eusebius (H. E. vi. 1) for instance, like the authors first quoted, uses ἐπιστολὴ and ἐπιστολαὶ in the same context when speaking of one and the same letter³.
If therefore we find that in another place Polycarp, referring again to the Epistle to the Philippians, uses the singular (ἐπιστολή)⁴, this circumstance will present no difficulty; for we have seen similar variations of usage in the passages of Thucydides and Alciphron, of Josephus and Eusebius, where the anomaly is rendered more striking by the fact that in these authors the singular and plural occur in close proximity.
But a later passage of this same father has been quoted to show that he carefully distinguishes between the singular and the plural of this word. 'The letters (ἐπιστολάς) of Ignatius,' he writes, 'which were sent to us by him, and such others as we had by us, we have sent to you, as ye commanded; all which (αἴτινες) are appended to this letter (ἐπιστολή); from which ye may derive great advantage' (§ 13). The plural here has been explained as referring to the two letters, the one to the Smyrnæans, the other to Polycarp, contained in the short Greek recension. This explanation, it will be seen, supposes either the genuineness of the short Greek recension of the Ignatian letters or the spuriousness of this portion of Polycarp's epistle. Into these questions it would be beside the purpose to enter here. I would only say that here again the ἐπιστολαὶ may very well be used of a single letter, and that on this supposition there is a certain propriety in the
¹ Comp. also Antiq. xiii. 4. 8.
² I owe a few of these references to Rettig Quæst. Phil. p. 38.
³ Comp. also H. E. vi. 43, quoted by Cotelier on Polyo. Phil. 3. The plural 'epistolæ' in Latin is used in the same way; Justin xi. 8, 12, Plin. N. II. xxxiii. 12, quoted by Fabric. Bibl. Græc. iv. p. 804 (ed. Harles).
⁴ Polyo. Phil. 11 'qui estis in principio epistolæ ejus,' where some word like 'laudati' should perhaps be supplied. Others however suppose the original Greek to have been οἱ ὄντες ἐν ἀρχῇ ἐπιστολαὶ αὐτοῦ, comparing for ἐν ἀρχῇ. Phil. iv. 15, and for ἐπιστολαὶ αὐτοῦ 2 Cor. iii. 2, 3.
He does not refer to a lost letter.
change from the plural to the singular, when the writer has occasion to speak of himself. For the plural ἐπιστολαί, which signifies properly 'directions, injunctions,' whenever it occurs in prose of a single epistle, seems to denote a missive of importance, such as a king's mandate or a bishop's pastoral; and its employment by Polycarp to designate his own letter would have jarred strangely with his pervading tone of humility, though it would fitly describe the communications of the blessed Apostle Paul (§ 3) or the holy martyr Ignatius (§ 13)¹.
On the whole then it would appear probable that Polycarp refers solely to the extant Epistle to the Philippians; for though the existence of other letters was seen to be in itself antecedently probable, yet it seems very unlikely that an epistle of St Paul, which had survived the opening of the second century and was then known to the Churches of Smyrna and Philippi, should so soon afterwards have passed wholly out of memory. Irenæus, the pupil of Polycarp, is evidently acquainted with only one Epistle of St Paul to the Philippians².
¹ By a curious coincidence Maximus uses the plural of Polycarp's own epistle: Dion. Areop. Op. 11. p. 93 (ed. Corder.), ἔχει δὲ καὶ ἐπιστολὰς ὁ αὐτὸς θεῖος Πολύκαρπος πρὸς Φιλιππησίους.
² Georgius Syncellus indeed (Chron. 1. p. 651 ed. Dind., a passage which I owe to Rettig Quest. Phil. p. 39) speaking of St Clement of Rome writes, τοίτου καὶ ὁ ἀπόστολος ἐν τῇ πρὸς Φιλιππησίους μέμνηται πρώτη ἐπιστολῇ εἰπών,
Μετὰ καὶ Κλήμεντος κ.τ.λ.: but it seems wholly incredible that Syncellus himself, and very unlikely that any authority quoted by him, should have been acquainted with more than one Epistle to the Philippians: and I can only account for the reading by supposing that a superfluous a crept into the text and was afterwards written out in full πρώτη.
{"canonical_mapping_status":"native_coordinates_only; no canonical mapping inferred","footnote_boundary_status":"whole_native_row_preserved; no independent-note segmentation or note-count claim","html_tags":{"i":6,"p":158},"id":"sqlite3:18d0fa08f9b61abe39b402806294c6cc80bd05266674df295094b04f2c75b3fd:commentaries:212","native_body_column":"text","native_module_context_literals":{"$context_sha256":"6a5da605c8557bc004c070d138969cc9df91b8441cd46e609333a901bec25f5a"},"native_module_metadata_ref":{"$context_sha256":"0fa22d44cfd532bf8ca61290c76d3112253de296bf0dd8291ae95151d9ec1b85"},"native_reference":{"book_number":570,"chapter_number_from":3,"chapter_number_to":3,"verse_number_from":1,"verse_number_to":1},"native_rowid":212,"native_table":"commentaries","projection":"HTML character data with explicit block newlines; no text-node deletion or whitespace folding; original HTML retained","public_import_allowed":false,"record_kind":"native-verse-keyed-module-record","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_family_classification":"sermonindex","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"09aebd8d930dd2fdf1b910e241841348590265f399e9112fe4111becef2e6137"},"source_html_sha256":"09aebd8d930dd2fdf1b910e241841348590265f399e9112fe4111becef2e6137","source_locator":{"$context_sha256":"2ce54c0d68ed7cbc9208da85eb19280dca0b3778e595c19dbe5dd07035f91ddf"},"source_origin_path":"SI-JBLIGHTFOOT.commentaries.SQLite3","source_sha256":"18d0fa08f9b61abe39b402806294c6cc80bd05266674df295094b04f2c75b3fd"}