Chapter XXV.
That Scripture uses the words “in” or “by,” ἐν, cf. note on p. 3, in place of “with.” Wherein
also it is proved that the word “and” has the same force as “with.”
58. It is, however, asked by our opponents, how it is that Scripture nowhere describes
the Spirit as glorified together with the Father and the Son, but carefully avoids the use of
the expression “with the Spirit,” while it everywhere prefers to ascribe glory “in Him” as
being the fitter phrase. I should, for my own part, deny that the word in [or by] implies
lower dignity than the word “with;” I should maintain on the contrary that, rightly under-
stood, it leads us up to the highest possible meaning. This is the case where, as we have
observed, it often stands instead of with; as for instance, “I will go into thy house in burnt
offerings,”1215 instead of with burnt offerings and “he brought them forth also by silver and
gold,”1216 that is to say with silver and gold and “thou goest not forth in our armies”1217
instead of with our armies, and innumerable similar passages. In short I should very much
like to learn from this newfangled philosophy what kind of glory the Apostle ascribed by
the word in, according to the interpretation which our opponents proffer as derived from
Scripture, for I have nowhere found the formula “To Thee, O Father, be honour and glory,
through Thy only begotten Son, by [or in] the Holy Ghost,”—a form which to our opponents
comes, so to say, as naturally as the air they breathe. You may indeed find each of these
37
clauses separately,1218 but they will nowhere be able to show them to us arranged in this
conjunction. If, then, they want exact conformity to what is written, let them give us exact
references. If, on the other hand, they make concession to custom, they must not make us
an exception to such a privilege.
59. As we find both expressions in use among the faithful, we use both; in the belief
that full glory is equally given to the Spirit by both. The mouths, however, of revilers of the
truth may best be stopped by the preposition which, while it has the same meaning as that
of the Scriptures, is not so wieldy a weapon for our opponents, (indeed it is now an object
of their attack) and is used instead of the conjunction and. For to say “Paul and Silvanus
and Timothy”1219 is precisely the same thing as to say Paul with Timothy and Silvanus; for
the connexion of the names is preserved by either mode of expression. The Lord says “The
Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost.”1220 If I say the Father and the Son with the Holy
1215 Ps. lxvi. 13, LXX.
1216 Ps. cv. 37.
1217 Ps. xliv. 9.
1218 In Eph. ii. 18 they are combined, but no Scriptural doxology uses ἐν of the Spirit.
1219 1 Thess. i. 1.
1220 Matt. xxviii. 19.
That Scripture uses the words “in” or “by,” ἐν, cf. note on p. 3, in place of “with.” Wherein also it is proved that the word “and” has the same force as “with.”
220
That Scripture uses the words “in” or “by,” , cf. note on p. 3, in place…