during the occurrence of events which occupied a period of some twenty years. And not
only was he a spectator, but took part in these transactions in such an official and authorit-
ative manner as Origen could never have assumed, either at Rome or elsewhere.
6
In this state of the controversy, commentators turned their attention towards Hippolytus,
in favour of whose authorship the majority of modern scholars have decided. The arguments
that have led to this conclusion, and those alleged by others against it, could not be adequately
discussed in a notice like the present. Suffice it to say, that such names as Jacobi, Gieseler,
Duncker, Schneidewin, Bernays, Bunsen, Wordsworth, and Döllinger, support the claims
of Hippolytus. The testimony of Dr. Döllinger, considering the extent of his theological
learning, and in particular his intimate acquaintance with the apostolic period in church
history, virtually, we submit, decides the question.16
For a biography of Hippolytus we have not much authentic materials. There can be no
reasonable doubt but that he was a bishop, and passed the greater portion of his life in Rome
and its vicinity. This assertion corresponds with the conclusion adopted by Dr. Döllinger,
who, however, refuses to allow that Hippolytus was, as is generally maintained, Bishop of
Portus, a harbour of Rome at the northern mouth of the Tiber, opposite Ostia. However,
it is satisfactory to establish, and especially upon such eminent authority as that of Dr.
Döllinger, the fact of Hippolytus’ connection with the Western Church, not only because
it bears on the investigation of the authorship of The Refutation, the writer of which affirms
his personal observation of what he records as occurring in his own time at Rome, but also
because it overthrows the hypothesis of those who contend that there were more Hippolytuses
than one—Dr. Döllinger shows that there is only one historical Hippolytus—or that the
East, and not Italy, was the sphere of his episcopal labours. Thus Le Moyne, in the seventeenth
century, a French writer resident in Leyden, ingeniously argues that Hippolytus was bishop
of Portus Romanorum (Aden), in Arabia. Le Moyne’s theory was adopted by some
celebrities, viz., Dupin, Tillemont, Spanheim, Basnage, and our own Dr. Cave. To this pos-
ition are opposed, among others, the names of Nicephorus, Syncellus, Baronius, Bellarmine,
Dodwell, Beveridge, Bull, and Archbishop Ussher. The judgment and critical accuracy of
Ussher is, on a point of this kind, of the highest value. Wherefore the question of Hippolytus
being bishop of Portus near Rome would also appear established, for the reasons laid down
16 Those who are desirous of examining it for themselves may consult Gieseler’s paper on Hippolytus, etc.,
in the Theologische Studien und Kritiken, 1853; Hergenröther, Theologische Quartalschrift, Tübingen, 1852;
Bunsen’s Hippolytus and His Age; Wordsworth’s St. Hippolytus; Dr. Döllinger’s Hippolytus und Kallistus: oder
die Römische Kirche in der ersten Hälfte des dritten Jahrhunderts, 1853; and Cruice’s Études sur de Nouveaux
Documents Historiques empruntés au livre des φιλοσοφούμενα, 1853. See also articles in the Quarterly Review,
1851; Ecclesiastic and Theologian, 1852, 1853; the Westminster Review, 1853; the Dublin Review, 1853, 1854; Le
Correspondent, t. xxxi.; and the Revue des Deux Mondes, 1865.
10
Introductory Notice.