affair in controversy.—Long before the sitting of the council, my people had sent to the
Reverend Mr. Clark of Salem Village, desiring him to write in opposition to my principles.
Which gave me occasion to write to Mr. Clark, that he might have true information what
my principles were. And in the time of the sitting of the council, I did, for their information,
make a public declaration of my principles before them and the church, in the meeting-
house, of the same import with that in my letter to Mr. Clark, and very much in the same
words. And then, afterwards, sent in to the council in writing, an extract of that letter, con-
taining the information I had given Mr. Clark, in the very words of my letter to him, that
the council might read and consider it at their leisure, and have a more certain and satisfact-
ory knowledge what my principles were. The extract which I sent in to them was in the fol-
lowing words:
“I am often, and I do not know but pretty generally in the country, represented as of a
new and odd opinion with respect to the terms of christian communion, and as being for
introducing a peculiar way of my own.—Whereas, I do not perceive that I differ at all from
the scheme of Dr. Watts, in his book entitled, The rational Foundation of a Christian Church,
and the Terms of Christian Communion; which, he says, is the common sentiment and
practice of all reformed churches. I had not seen this book of Dr. Watts’s when I published
what I have written on the subject. But yet, I think, my sentiments, as I have expressed them,
are at exactly agreeable to what he lays down, at if I had been his pupil. Nor do I at all go
beyond what Dr. Doddridge plainly shows to be his sentiments, in his Rise and Progress of
Religion, and his Sermons on Regeneration, and his Paraphrase and Notes on the New
cxcix
Testament. Nor indeed, Sir, when I consider the sentiments you have expressed in your
letters to Major Pomroy and Mr. Billing, can I perceive but that they come exactly to the
same thing that I maintain. You suppose, the sacraments are not converting ordinances:
but that, as seals of the covenant, they presuppose conversion especially in the adult; and that
it is visible saintship, or, in other words, a credible profession of faith and repentance, a solemn
consent to the gospel covenant, joined with a good conversation, and competent measure of
christian knowledge, is what gives a gospel-right to all sacred ordinances: but that it is necessary
to those that come to these ordinances, and in those that profess a consent to the gospel coven-
ant, that they be sincere in their profession or at least should think themselves so.—The great
thing which I have scrupled in the established method of this church’s proceeding, and
which I dare no longer go on in, is their publicly assenting to the form of words rehearsed
on occasion of their admission to the communion, without pretending thereby to mean any
such thing as a hearty consent to the terms of the gospel-covenant, or to mean any such
faith or repentance as belong to the covenant of grace, and are the grand conditions of that
covenant. It being, at the same time that the words are used, their known and established
principle, which they openly profess and proceed, upon, that men may and ought to use
these words, and mean no such thing, but something else of a nature far inferior; which I
418
A Farewell Sermon