Evasion III. It is said by many opposers of the doctrine of original sin, that the corruption
of mankind may be owing not to a depraved nature, but to bad example. And I think we
must understand Dr. T. as having respect to the powerful influence of bad instruction and
example, when he says, (p. 118.) “The Gentiles in their heathen state, when incorporated
into the body of the gentile world, were without strength, unable to help or recover them-
selves.” And in several other places to the like purpose. If there was no depravity of nature,
what else could there be but bad instruction and example, to hinder the heathen world, as
a collective body, (for as such Dr. T. speaks of them, as may be seen p. 117, 118.) from
emerging out of their corruption, on the rise of each new generation? As to their bad instruc-
tion, our author insists upon it, that the heathen, notwithstanding all their disadvantages,
had sufficient light to know God, and do their whole duty. Therefore it must be chiefly bad
example, according to him, that rendered their case helpless.
Now concerning this way of accounting for the corruption of the world, by the influence
of bad example, I would observe,
1. It is accounting for the thing by the thing itself. It is accounting for the corruption of
the world by the corruption of the world. For, that bad examples are general all over the
world to be followed by others, and have been so from the beginning, is only an instance,
or rather a description, of that corruption of the world which is to be accounted for. If
mankind are naturally no more inclined to evil than good, then how come there to be so
many more bad examples than good ones, in all ages? And if there are not, how come to
bad examples that are set, to be so much more followed than the good? If the propensity of
man’s nature be not to evil, how comes the current of general example, every where, and at
all times, to be so much to evil? And when opposition has been made by good examples,
how comes it to pass that it has had so little effect to stem the stream of general wicked
practice?
I think from the brief account the Scripture gives us of the behaviour of our first parents,
and of the expressions of their faith and hope in God’s revealed mercy, we have reason to
suppose, that before ever they had any children, they repented, were pardoned, and became
truly pious. So that God planted the world at first with a noble vine; and at the beginning of
their generations, he set the stream of example the right way. And we see, that children are
more apt to follow the example of their parents, than of any others; especially in early youth,
their forming time, when those habits are generally contracted, which abide by them all
their days. Besides, Adam’s children had no other examples to follow, but those of their
parents. How therefore came the stream so soon to turn, and to proceed the contrary way,
with so violent a current? When mankind became so universally and desperately corrupt,
as not to be fit to live on earth any longer, and the world was every where full of bad examples,
God destroyed them all at once—except righteous Noah and his family—in order to remove
those bad examples, and that the world might be planted again with good example, and the
1000
SECTION IX. Several evasions considered.