hidings of his face. Great numbers in this country proceed on the supposition, in their
opinions and practice, that there really is such a manner of believing, such a kind of faith
as this, viz. a confident believing and firm trusting in God in the dark, in the sense just
mentioned, which is the subject matter of Divine prescription, and which many actually
have. Indeed there are innumerable instances of such as are apparently in a most negligent,
apostate, and every way unchristian and wicked frame; who yet, encouraged by this principle,
retain a strong confidence of their piety, and imagine that herein they do their duty and
glorify God, under the notion of trusting God in the dark, and hoping against hope, and
not relying on their own righteousness; and they suppose it would show a legal spirit to do
otherwise. I thought it would be manifest to every reader that I was arguing against such
persons as these.
You say, ‘It merits consideration, whether the believer should ever doubt of his state,
on any account whatever, because doubting, as opposed to believing, is absolutely sinful.’
Here, Sir, you seem to suppose that a person’s doubting of his own good estate, is the proper
opposite of faith; and these and some other expressions in your letter seem to suppose that
doubting of one’s good estate, and unbelief, are the same thing; and so, that confidence in
one’s good estate, and faith, are the same thing. This, I acknowledge, I do not understand; I
do not suppose faith, and a person’s believing that he has faith, to be the same thing. Nor do
I take unbelief, or being without faith, and doubting whether he has it, to be the same thing,
but entirely different. I should have been glad either that you had taken a little more notice
of what I say on this head, p. 79, 80, or that you had said something to convince me that I
am wrong in this point. The exercise of faith is doubtless the way to be delivered from darkness,
deadness, backsliding, &c. or rather is the deliverance; as forsaking sin is the way to deliver-
ance from sin, and is the deliverance itself. The exercise of grace is doubtless the way to de-
liverance from a graceless frame, which consists in the want of the exercise of grace. But as
to what you say, or seem to intimate, that a person’s being confident of his own good estate,
is the way to be delivered from darkness, deadness, backsliding, and prevailing iniquity; I
think, whoever supposes this to be God’s method of delivering his saints, when sunk into
an evil, careless, carnal, and unchristian frame, first to assure them of their good estate and
his favour, while they yet remain in such a frame, and to make that the means of their deliv-
erance, does surely mistake God’s method of dealing with such persons. Among all the
multitudes I have had opportunity to observe, I never knew one dealt with after this manner.
I have known many brought back from great declension, who appeared to me to be real
saints; but it was in a way very different from this. In the first place, conscience has been
awakened, and they have been brought into distressing fears of the wrath of God. Thus they
have become the subjects of a new work of humiliation, and have been led deeply to feel
that they deserve his wrath, even while they have feared it, before God has delivered them
from their apprehensions, and comforted them with a renewed sense of his favour.
176
CHAPTER XIV. Mistakes extensively prevalent at this time, as to the nature…