pardon him, if he were as humble as he is miserable. But how can you pretend to find fault
with God for His anger against both friends and enemies when they sin, when the god of
your fancies first under compulsion compels his own members to go to be devoured by sin,
281
and then condemns them to remain in darkness? Though he does this, you say that it will
not be in anger. But will he not be ashamed to punish, or to appear to punish, those from
whom he should ask pardon in words such as these: "Forgive me, I beseech you. You are
my members; could I treat you thus, except from necessity? You know yourselves, that you
were sent here because a formidable enemy had arisen; and now you must remain here to
prevent his rising again"? Again, is it not better to slay thousands of men for trifling faults,
or for nothing, than to cast into the abyss of sin, and to condemn to the punishment of
eternal imprisonment, God’s own members, his substance—in fact, God himself? It cannot
properly be said of the real substance of God that it has the choice of sinning or not sinning,
for God’s substance is absolutely unchangeable. God cannot sin, as He cannot deny Himself.
Man, on the contrary, can sin and deny God, or he can choose not to do so. But suppose
the members of your god had, like a rational human soul, the choice of sinning or not sinning;
they might perhaps be justly punished for heinous offenses by confinement in the mass of
darkness. But you cannot attribute to these parts a liberty which you deny to God himself.
For if God had not given them up to sin, he would have been forced to sin himself, by the
prevalence of the race of darkness. But if there was no danger of being thus forced, it was
a sin to send these parts to a place where they incurred this danger. To do so, indeed, from
free choice is a crime deserving the torment which your god unnaturally inflicts upon his
own parts, more than the conduct of these parts in going by his command to a place where
they lost the power of living in righteousness. But if God himself was in danger of being
forced to sin by invasion and capture, unless he had secured himself first by the misconduct
and then by the punishment of his own parts, there can have been no free-will either in your
god or in his parts. Let him not set himself up as judge, but confess himself a criminal. For
though he was forced against his own will, he professes to pass a righteous sentence in
condemning those whom he knows to have suffered evil rather than done it; making this
profession that he may not be thought of as having been conquered; as if it could do a beggar
any good to be called prosperous and happy. Surely it would have been better for your god
to have spared neither righteous nor wicked in indiscriminate punishment (which is Faustus’
last charge against our God), than to have been so cruel to his own members,—first giving
them up to incurable contamination, and then, as if that was not enough, accusing them
falsely of misconduct. Faustus declares that they justly suffer this severe and eternal punish-
ment, because they allowed themselves to be led astray from their original brightness, and
became hostile to sacred light. But the reason of this, as Faustus says, was that they were so
greedily devoured in the first assault of the princes of darkness, that they were unable to
recover themselves, or to separate themselves from the hostile principle. These souls,
479
Faustus states his objections to the morality of the law and the prophets,…