§9.
In charging Basil with not defending his faith at the
time of the ‘Trials,’ he lays himself open to the same
charge.
He hints at a certain locality
where this trial for heresy took place; but he gives us no certain
indication where it was, and the reader is obliged to guess in the
dark. Thither, he tells us, a congress of picked representatives from
all quarters was summoned; and he is at his best here, placing before
our eyes with some vigorous strokes the preparation of the event which
he pretends took place. Then, he says, a trial in which he would have
had to run for his very life was put into the hands of certain
arbitrators, to whom our Teacher and Master who was present gave his
charge
85
; and as all the voting power was thus won over
to the enemies’ side, he yielded the position
86
,
fled from the place, and hunted everywhere for some hearth and home;
and he is great, in this graphic sketch
87
, in
arraigning the cowardice of our hero; as any one who likes may see by
looking at what he has written. But I cannot stop to give specimens
here of the bitter gall of his utterances; I must pass on to that, for
the sake of which I mentioned all this.
Where, then, was that unnamed
spot in which this examination of his teachings was to take place? What
was this occasion when the best then were collected for a trial? Who
were these men who hurried over land and sea to share in these labours?
What was this ‘expectant world that hung upon the issue of the
voting?’ Who was ‘the arranger of the trial?’
However, let us consider that he invented all that to swell out the
importance of his story, as boys at school are apt to do in
their
fictitious conversations of this kind; and let him only
tell us who that ‘terrible combatant’ was whom our Master
shrunk from encountering. If this also is a fiction, let him be the
winner again, and have the advantage of his vain words. We will say
nothing: in the useless fight with shadows the real victory is to
decline conquering in
that.
But if he speaks of the events at
Constantinople and means the assembly there, and is in this fever of
literary indignation at tragedies enacted there, and means himself by
that great and redoubtable athlete, then we would display the reasons
why, though present on the occasion, we did not plunge into the
fight.
Now let this man who upbraids that hero with his cowardice tell us
whether
he
went down into the thick of the fray, whether
he
uttered one syllable in defence of his own orthodoxy, whether
he
made any vigorous peroration, whether
he
victoriously
grappled with the foe? He cannot tell us that, or he manifestly
contradicts himself, for he owns that by his default he received the
adverse verdict. If it was a duty to speak at the actual time of the
trial (for that is the law which he lays down for us in his book), then
why was he then condemned by default? If on the other hand he did well
in observing silence before such dicasts, how arbitrarily
88
he praises himself, but blames us, for silence
at such a time! What can be more absurdly unjust than this! When two
treatises have been put forth since the time of the trial, he declares
that his apology, though written so very long after, was in time, but
reviles that which answered his own as quite too late! Surely he ought
to have abused Basil’s intended counter-statement before it was
actually made; but this is not found amongst his other complaints.
Knowing as he did what Basil was going to write when the time of the
trial had passed away, why in the world did he not find fault with it
there and then? In fact it is clear from his own confession that he
never made that apology in the trial itself. I will repeat again his
words:—‘We confess that we were condemned by
default;’ and he adds why; ‘Evil-disposed persons had been
passed as jurymen,’ or rather, to use his own phrase,
‘there was a packed panel of them where a jury ought to have
sat.’ Whereas, on the other hand, it is clear from another
passage in his book that he attests that his apology was made ‘at
the proper time.’ It runs thus:—“That I was urged to
make this apology at the proper time and in the proper manner from no
pretended reasons, but compelled to do so on behalf of those who went
security for me, is clear from facts and also from this man’s
words.” He adroitly twists his words round to meet every possible
objection; but what will he say to this? ‘It was not right to
keep silent during the trial.’ Then why was Eunomius speechless
during that same trial? And why is his apology, coming as it did after
the trial, in good time? And if in good time, why is Basil’s
controversy with him not in good time?
But the remark of that holy
father is especially true, that Eunomius in pretending to make an
apology really gave his teaching the support he wished to give it; and
that genuine emulator of Phineas’ zeal, destroying as he does
with the sword of the Word every spiritual fornicator, dealt in the
‘Answer to his blasphemy’ a sword-thrust that was
calculated at once to heal a soul and to destroy a heresy. If he
resists that stroke, and with a soul deadened by apostacy will not
admit the cure, the blame rests with him who chooses the evil, as the
Gentile proverb says. So far for Eunomius’ treatment of truth,
and of us: and now the law of former times, which allows an equal
return on those who are the first to injure, might prompt us to
discharge on him a counter-shower of abuse, and, as he is a very easy
subject for this, to be very liberal of it, so as to outdo the pain
which he has inflicted: for if he was so rich in insolent invective
against one who gave no chance for calumny, how many of such epithets
might we not expect to find for those who have satirized that saintly
life? But we have been taught from the first by that scholar of the
Truth to be scholars of the Gospel ourselves, and therefore we will not
take an eye for an eye, nor a tooth for a tooth; we know well that all
the evil that happens admits of being annihilated by its opposite, and
that no bad word and no bad deed would ever develope into such
desperate wickedness, if one good one could only be got in to break the
continuity of the vicious stream. Therefore the routine of insolence
and abusiveness is checked from repeating itself by long-suffering:
whereas if insolence is met with insolence and abuse with abuse, you
will but feed with itself this monster-vice, and increase it
vastly.
85
ὑποφωνεῖν
86
Sozomen
(vi. 26): “After his (Eunomius) elevation to the bishopric of
Cyzicus he was accused by his own clergy of introducing innovations.
Eudoxius obliged him to undergo a public trial and give an account of
his doctrines to the people: finding, however, no fault in him,
Eudoxius exhorted him to return to Cyzicus. He replied he could not
remain with people who regarded him with suspicion, and it is said
seized this opportunity to secede from communion.”
87
ὑπογραφῇ
; or else ‘on the subject of Basil’s
charge.’
88
τίς ἡ
ἀποκλήρωσις
: this is a favourite word with Origen and
Gregory.