epistles which Eusebius wrote to Alexander and to Euphration; his defenders have drawn
their arguments chiefly from the works which he produced subsequent to the year 325; while
the exact bearing of the expressions used in his works produced before the controversy
broke out has always been a matter of sharp dispute. Lee has abundantly shown his Contra
Marcel., his De Eccl. Theol., his Thephania (which was written after the Council of Nicæa,
and not, as Lee supposes, before it), and other later works, to be thoroughly orthodox and
to contain nothing which a trinitarian might not have written. In his Hist. Eccl., Præparatio
14
Evang., Demonstratio Evang., and other earlier works, although we find some expressions
employed which it would not have been possible for an orthodox trinitarian to use after the
Council of Nicæa, at least without careful limitation to guard against misapprehension,
there is nothing even in these works which requires us to believe that he accepted the doc-
trines of Arius’ predecessor, Lucian of Antioch; that is, there is nothing distinctly and posit-
ively Arianistic about them, although there are occasional expressions which might lead the
reader to expect that the writer would become an Arian if he ever learned of Arius’ doctrines.
But if there is seen to be a lack of emphasis upon the divinity of the Son, or rather a lack of
clearness in the conception of the nature of that divinity, it must be remembered that there
was at this time no especial reason for emphasizing and defining it, but there was on the
contrary very good reason for laying particular stress upon the subordination of the Son
over against Sabellianism, which was so widely prevalent during the third century, and
which was exerting an influence even over many orthodox theologians who did not con-
sciously accept Sabellianistic tenets. That Eusebius was a decided subordinationist must be
plain to every one that reads his works with care, especially his earlier ones. It would be
surprising if he had not been, for he was born at a time when Sabellianism (monarchianism)
was felt to be the greatest danger to which orthodox christology was exposed, and he was
trained under the influence of the followers of Origen, who had made it one of his chief
aims to emphasize the subordination of the Son over against that very monarchianism.1
1 It is interesting to notice that the creed of the Cæsarean church which Eusebius presented at the Council
of Nice contains a clause which certainly looks as if it had been composed in opposition to the familiar formula
of the Sabellians: “The same one is the Father, the same one the Son, the same one the Holy Spirit” (τὸν αὐτὸν
εἶναι πατέρα, τὸν αὐτὸν εἶναι υἱ& 232·ν, τὸν αὐτὸν εἶναι ἅγιον πνεῦμα; see Epiphan. Hær. LXII. 1; and compare
the statement made in the same section, that the Sabellians taught that God acts in three forms: in the form of
the Father, as creator and lawgiver; in the form of the Son, as redeemer; and in the form of the Spirit, as life-
giver, etc.). The clause of the Cæsarean creed referred to runs as follows: “That the Father is truly Father, the
Son truly Son, and the Holy Spirit truly Holy Spirit” (πατέρα ἀληθῶς πατέρα, καὶ υἱ& 232·ν ἀληθῶς υἱ& 232·ν,
καὶ πνεῦμα ἅγιον ἀληθῶς ἅγιον). It is significant that in the revised creed adopted by the Council these words
are omitted, evidently because the occasion for them no longer existed, since not Sabellianism but Arianism
was the heresy combated; and because, more than that, the use of them would but weaken the emphasis which
the Council wished to put upon the essential divinity of all three persons.
23
The Outbreak of the Arian Controversy. The Attitude of Eusebius.