heresy. How great this crime is in the judgment of God Himself, you may see by reading
what without doubt you have read ere now. You will find that Dathan and Abiram were
swallowed up by an opening of the earth beneath them,2088 and that all the others who had
conspired with them were devoured by fire breaking forth in the midst of them. As a
warning to men to shun this crime, the Lord God signalized its commission with this imme-
diate punishment, that He might show what He reserves for the final recompense of persons
guilty of a similar transgression, whom His great forbearance spares for a time. We do not,
indeed, find fault with the reasons by which you excuse your tolerating Optatus among you.
We do not blame you, because at the time when he was denounced for his furious conduct
in the mad abuse of power, when he was impeached by the groans of all Africa,—groans in
which you also shared, if you are what good report declares you to be,—a report which, God
knows, I most willingly believe,—you forbore from excommunicating him, lest he should
under such sentence draw away many with him, and rend your communion asunder with
the frenzy of schism. But this is the thing which is itself an indictment against you at the
bar of God, O brother Emeritus, that although you saw that the division of the party of
Donators was so great an evil, that it was thought better that Optatus should be tolerated
in your communion than that division should be introduced among you, you nevertheless
perpetuate the evil which was wrought in the division of the Church of Christ by your
forefathers.
367
5. Here perhaps you will be disposed, under the exigencies of debate, to attempt to defend
Optatus. Do not so, I beseech you; do not so, my brother: it would not become you; and if
it would perchance be seemly for any one to do it (though, in fact, nothing is seemly which
is wrong), it assuredly would be unseemly for Emeritus to defend Optatus. Perhaps you
reply that it would as little become you to accuse him. Granted, by all means. Take, then,
the course which lies between defending and accusing him. Say, “Every man shall bear his
own burden;”2089 “Who art thou that judgest another man’s servant?”2090 If, then, notwith-
standing the testimony of all Africa,—nay more, of all regions to which the name of Gildo
was carried, for Optatus was not less notorious than he,—you have not dared to pronounce
judgment concerning Optatus, lest you should rashly decide in regard to one unknown to
you, is it, I ask, either possible or right for us, proceeding solely on your testimony, to pro-
nounce sentence rashly upon persons whom we do not know? Is it not enough that you
should charge them with things of which you have no certain knowledge, without our pro-
nouncing them guilty of things of which we know as little as yourselves? For even though
Optatus were in peril through the falsehood of detractors, you defend not him, but yourself,
2088 Num. xvi. 31–35.
2089 Gal. vi. 5.
2090 Rom. xiv. 4.
817
To Emeritus