ought not to think that His obedience was prior to His generation! Now if he had not added
122
this defining clause, who without it would have been sufficiently silly and idiotic to fancy
that His generation was bestowed on Him by His Father, as a reward of the obedience of
Him Who before His generation had showed due subjection and obedience? But that no
one may too readily extract matter for laughter from these remarks, let each consider that
even the folly of the words has in it something worthy of tears. For what he intends to estab-
lish by these observations is something of this kind, that His obedience is part of His nature,
so that not even if He willed it would it be possible for Him not to be obedient.
For he says that He was so constituted that His nature was adapted to obedience alone405,
just as among instruments that which is fashioned with regard to a certain figure necessarily
produces in that which is subjected to its operation the form which the artificer implanted
in the construction of the instrument, and cannot possibly trace a straight line upon that
which receives its mark, if its own working is in a curve; nor can the instrument, if fashioned
to draw a straight line, produce a circle by its impress. What need is there of any words of
ours to reveal how great is the profanity of such a notion, when the heretical utterance of
itself proclaims aloud its monstrosity? For if He was obedient for this reason only that He
was so made, then of course He is not on an equal footing even with humanity, since on
this theory, while our soul is self-determining and independent, choosing as it will with
sovereignty over itself that which is pleasing to it, He on the contrary exercises, or rather
experiences, obedience under the constraint of a compulsory law of His nature, while His
nature suffers Him not to disobey, even if He would. For it was “as the result of being Son,
and being begotten, that He has thus shown Himself obedient in words and obedient in
acts.” Alas, for the brutish stupidity of this doctrine! Thou makest the Word obedient to
words, and supposest other words prior to Him Who is truly the Word, and another Word
of the Beginning is mediator between the Beginning and the Word that was in the Beginning,
conveying to Him the decision. And this is not one only: there are several words, which
Eunomius makes so many links of the chain between the Beginning and the Word, and
which abuse His obedience as they think good. But what need is there to linger over this
idle talk? Any one can see that even at that time with reference to which S. Paul says that
He became obedient (and he tells us that He became obedient in this wise, namely, by be-
coming for our sakes flesh, and a servant, and a curse, and sin),—even then, I say, the Lord
of glory, Who despised the shame and embraced suffering in the flesh, did not abandon His
free will, saying as He does, “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up406;” and
405 If this phrase is a direct quotation from Eunomius, it is probably from some other context: its grammat-
ical structure does not connect it with what has gone before, nor is it quite clear where the quotation ends, or
whether the illustration of the instrument is Eunomius’ own, or is Gregory’s exposition of the statement of Eu-
nomius.
406 S. John ii. 19
234
After expounding the high estate of the Almighty, the Eternity of the Son,…