of absurdity and self-contradiction: they hold, that the old law given to Adam, which requires
perfect obedience, is entirely repealed, and that instead of it we are put under a new law,
which requires no more than imperfect sincere obedience, in compliance with our poor,
infirm, impotent circumstances since the fall, whereby we are unable to perform that perfect
obedience that was required by the first law; for they strenuously maintain, that it would be
unjust in God to require any thing of us that is beyond our present power and ability to
perform; and yet they hold, that Christ died to satisfy for the imperfections of our obedience,
that so our imperfect obedience might be accepted instead of perfect. Now, how can these
things hang together? I would ask, What law these imperfections of our obedience are a
breach of? If they are not a breach of no law, then they are not sins; and if they be not sins,
what need of Christ’s dying to satisfy for them? but if they are sins, and so the breach of
some law, what law is it? They cannot be a breach of their new law, for that requires no
other than imperfect obedience, or obedience with imperfections; and they cannot be a
breach of the old law, for that they say is entirely abolished, and we never were under it; and
we cannot break a law that we never were under. They say it would not be just in God to
exact of us perfect obedience, because it would not be just in God to require more of us than
we can perform in our present state, and to punish us for failing of it; and therefore, by their
own scheme, the imperfections of our obedience do not deserve to be punished. What need
therefore of Christ’s dying to satisfy for them? What need of Christ’s suffering to satisfy for
that which is no fault, and in its own nature deserves no suffering? What need of Christ’s
dying to purchase that our imperfect obedience should be accepted, when according to their
scheme it would be unjust in itself that any other obedience than imperfect should be re-
quired? What need of Christ’s dying to make way for God’s accepting such an obedience,
as it would in itself be unjust in him not to accept? Is there any need of Christ’s dying to
persuade God not to do unjustly? If it be said, that Christ died to satisfy that law for us, that
630
so we might not be under that law, but might be delivered from it, that so there might be
room for us to be under a more mild law; still I would inquire, What need of Christ’s dying
that we might not be under a law that (according to their scheme) it would in itself be unjust
that we should be under, because in our present state we are not able to keep it? What need
of Christ’s dying that we might not be under a law that it would be unjust that we should
be under, whether Christ died or no?
Thus far I have argued principally from reason, and the nature of things:—I proceed
now to the
Second argument, which is, That this is a doctrine which the Holy Scriptures, the revel-
ation that God has given us of his mind and will—by which alone we can never come to
know how those who have offended God can come to be accepted of him, and justified in
his sight—is exceeding full. The apostle Paul is abundant in teaching, that “we are justified
by faith alone, without the works of the law!” There is no one doctrine that he insists so
2309
DISCOURSE. I. Justification by Faith alone.