Fortunatus said: Nor have I said that the soul is like God. But because you have said
that the soul is an artificial thing, and that there is nothing besides God, I ask whence then
God invented the substance of the soul?
13. Augustin said: Only bear in mind that I reply to your interrogations, but that you
do not reply to mine. I say that the soul was made by God as all other things that were made
by God; and that among the things that God Almighty made the principal place was given
to the soul. But if you ask whence God made the soul, remember that you and I agree in
confessing that God is almighty. But he is not almighty who seeks the assistance of any
material whence he may make what he will. From which it follows, that according to our
faith, all things that God made through His Word and Wisdom, He made out of nothing.
For so we read: "He ordered and they were made; He commanded and they were created."232
Fortunatus said: Do all things have their existence from God’s command?
14. Augustin said: So I believe, but all things which were made.
Fortunatus said: As things made they agree, but because they are unsuitable to them-
selves, therefore on this account it follows, that there is not one substance, although from
the same order of the One they came to the composition and fashioning of this world. But
it is plain in the things themselves that there is no similarity between darkness and light,
truth and falsehood, death and life, soul and body, and other similar things which differ
from each other both in names and appearances. And for good reason did our Lord say:
"The tree which my heavenly Father has not planted shall be rooted up and cast into the
fire, because it brings not forth good fruit:"233 and that the tree has been rooted up. Hence
truly it follows from the reason of things that there are two substances in this world which
agree in forms and in names, of which one belongs to corporeal natures, but the other is
the eternal substance of the omnipotent Father, which we believe to be God’s substance.
15. Augustin said: Those contrary things that move you so that we think adversely,
have happened on account of our sin, that is, on account of the sin of man. For God made
all things good, and ordered them well; but He did not make sin, and our voluntary sin is
the only thing that is called evil. There is another kind of evil, which is the penalty of sin.
Since therefore there are two kinds of evil, sin and the penalty of sin, sin does not pertain
to God; the penalty of sin pertains to the avenger. For as God is good who constituted all
things, so He is just in taking vengeance on sin. Since therefore all things are ordered in
the best possible way, which seem to us now to be adverse, it has deservedly happened to
fallen man who was unwilling to keep the law of God. For God gave free will to the rational
soul which is in man. For thus it would have been possible to have merit, if we should be
good voluntarily and not of necessity. Since therefore it behooves us to be good not of ne-
232 Ps. cxlviii. 5.
233 Matt. xv. 13, and iii. 10.
193
Disputation of the First Day.