Christians, without moral evidence (which is something positive, and not a mere negation
of evidence of the contrary) of gospel-holiness.
In p. 82. of my book I suppose, that none at all do truly subject themselves to Christ as
their master, but those who graciously subject themselves to him, and are delivered from
the reigning power of sin. Mr. W. suggests, (p. 83. d.) that herein I beg the question. For
which there is no pretext, not only as this is no known point in controversy between the
parties in this debate; but also as it is a point I do not take for granted, but offer this argument
to prove it, that they who have no grace, are under the reigning power of sin, and no man
can truly subject himself to two such contrary masters, at the same time, as Christ and sin.
I think this argument sufficient to obtain the point, without begging it. And besides, this
doctrine, that they who have no grace do not truly subject themselves to Christ, was no
point in question between me and Mr. W. But a point wherein we were fully agreed, and
wherein he had before expressed himself as fully, and more fully, than I. In his sermons on
Christ a King and Witness, (p. 18. b.) he speaks of all such as do not depend on Christ, believe
in him, and give up themselves and all to him, as not true subjects to Christ; but enemies
to him, and his kingdom. We have expressions to the same purpose again, in p. 74. and 91.
and in p. 94. d. e. of the same book, he says, “It is utterly inconsistent with the nature of the
obedience of the gospel, that it should be a forced subjection.—No man is a subject of Christ,
who does not make the laws and will of Christ his choice, and desire to be governed by him,
and to live in subjection to the will of Christ, as good and fit, and best to be the rule of his
living, and way to his happiness. A forced obedience to Christ is no obedience. It is in terms
a contradiction. Christ draws men with the cords of love, and the bands of a man. Our Lord
has himself expressly determined this point. There are other passages in the same book to
the same purpose. So that I had no need to beg this point of Mr. W. since he had given it
largely, and that in full measure, and over and over again, without begging.
In p. 120. b. he observes, ” That to say, such a profession of internal invisible things is
the rule to direct the church in admission,—is to hide the parallel, and beg the question. For
the question here is about the persons’ right to come, and not about the church’s admitting
them.” Here Mr. W. would make us believe, that he does not know what begging the question
is: for it is evident, his meaning is, that my saying so is beside the question. But to say
something beside the question, is a different thing from begging the question, as has been
observed. My saying, that a profession of invisible things is the church’s rule in admission,
is not begging the question: because it is not, nor ever was, any thing in question. For Mr.
S. and Mr. W. himself are full in it, that a profession of invisible things, such as a believing
that Christ is the Son of God, &c. is the church’s rule. Yea, Mr. W. is express in it, that a
credible profession and visibility of gospel-holiness is the church’s rule, p. 139. Nor is my
saying as above, beside the question then, in hand, relating to the church of Israel admitting
to the priesthood, those that could not find their register. For that wholly relates to the rule
1989
SECTION VII. Begging the question.