CHAP. XVIII. CHRISTIAN RELIGION. 267
CHAPTER XVIII.
THE INSTRUMENTALITY OF THE WICKED EMPLOYED BY GOD,
WHILE HE CONTINUES FREE FROM EVERY TAINT.1
This last chapter of the First Book consists of three parts : I. It hav
ing been said above that God bends all the reprobate, and even Satan
himself, at his will, three objections are started. First, that this happens
by the permission, not by the will of God. To this objection there is a
twofold reply, the one, that angels and men, good and bad, do nothing
but what is appointed by God ; the second, that all movements are se
cretly directed to their end by the hidden inspiration of God, sec. 1, 2.
II. A second objection is, that there are two contrary wills in God, if by
a secret counsel he decrees what he openly prohibits by his law. This
objection refuted, sec. 3. III. The third objection is, that God is made
the author of all wickedness, when he is said not only to use the agency
of the wicked, but also to govern their counsels and affections, and that
therefore the wicked are unjustly punished. This objection refuted in
the last section.
Sections.
1. The carnal mind the source of the objections which are raised against
the Providence of God. A primary objection, making a distinction
between the permission and the will of God, refuted. Angels and
men, good and bad, do nought but what has been decreed by God.
This proved by examples.
2. All hidden movements directed to their end by the unseen but right
eous instigation of God. Examples, with answers to objections.
3. These objections originate in a spirit of pride and blasphemy. Ob
jection, that there must be two contrary wills in God, refuted. Why
the one simple will of God seems to us as if it were manifold.
4. Objection, that God is the author of sin, refuted by examples.
Augustine's answer and admonition.
1. FROM other passages, in which God is said to draw
or bend Satan himself, and all the reprobate, to his will,
a more difficult question arises. For the carnal mind can
scarcely comprehend how, when acting by their means, he
1 See Calvin, adv. Libertinos, cap. xv. xvi., and Augustin. de Ordine, Lib. i. and ii., where he admirably discusses the question, Whether the
order of Divine Providence includes all good and evil ?