17. And while they were thus stoning him one of the priests of the sons of Rechab, the
son of the Rechabites,509 who are mentioned by Jeremiah the prophet,510 cried out, saying,
‘Cease, what do ye? The just one prayeth for you.’511
127
18. And one of them, who was a fuller, took the club with which he beat out clothes and
struck the just man on the head. And thus he suffered martyrdom.512 And they buried him
on the spot, by the temple, and his monument still remains by the temple.513 He became a
509 ῾Ραχαβείμ, which is simply the reproduction in Greek letters of the Hebrew plural, and is equivalent to
“the Rechabites.” But Hegesippus uses it without any article as if it were the name of an individual, just as he
uses the name ῾Ρηχ€β which immediately precedes. The Rechabites were a tribe who took their origin from Je-
honadab, the son of Rechab, who appears from 1 Chron. ii. 55 to have belonged to a branch of the Kenites, the
Arabian tribe which came into Palestine with the Israelites. Jehonadab enjoined upon his descendants a nomadic
and ascetic mode of life, which they observed with great strictness for centuries, and received a blessing from
God on account of their steadfastness (Jer. xxxv. 19). That a Rechabite, who did not belong to the tribe of Judah,
nor even to the genuine people of Israel, should have been a priest seems at first sight inexplicable. Different
solutions have been offered. Some think that Hegesippus was mistaken,—the source from which he took his
account having confounded this ascetic Rechabite with a priest,—but this is hardly probable. Plumptre, in Smith’s
Bib. Dict. art. Rechabites (which see for a full account of the tribe), thinks that the blessing pronounced upon
them by God (Jer. xxxv. 19) included their solemn adoption among the people of Israel, and their incorporation
into the tribe of Levi, and therefore into the number of the priests. Others (e.g. Tillemont, H. E. I. p. 633) have
supposed that many Jews, including also priests, embraced the practices and the institutions of the Rechabites
and were therefore identified with them. The language here, however, seems to imply a native Rechabite, and
it is probable that Hegesippus at least believed this person to be such, whether his belief was correct or not. See
Routh, I. p. 243 sq.
510 See Jer. xxxv
511 In Epiphanius, Hær. LXXVIII. 14, these words are put into the mouth of Simeon, the son of Clopas; from
which some have concluded that Simeon had joined the order of the Rechabites; but there is no ground for such
an assumption. The Simeon of Epiphanius and the Rechabite of Hegesippus are not necessarily identical. They
represent simply varieties of the original account, and Epiphanius’, as the more exact, was undoubtedly the later
tradition, and an intentional improvement upon the vagueness of the original.
512 Clement (in chap. 5, §4, above), who undoubtedly used the account of Hegesippus as his source, describes
the death of James as taking place in the same way, but omits the stoning which preceded. Josephus, on the
other hand (quoted below), mentions only the stoning. But Hegesippus’ account, which is the fullest that we
have gives us the means of reconciling the briefer accounts of Clement and of Josephus, and we have no reason
to think either account incorrect.
513 Valesius remarks that the monument (στήλη) could not have stood through the destruction of Jerusalem
until the time of Hegesippus, nor could James have been buried near the temple, as the Jews always buried their
dead without the city walls. Tillemont attempted to meet the difficulty by supposing that James was thrown
from a pinnacle of the temple overlooking the Valley of Jehoshaphat, and therefore fell without the walls, where
231
The Martyrdom of James, who was called the Brother of the Lord.