us1938 right by the same instruction as would benefit the Anomœan1939. The controversy
with the Manichee is profitless against the Jew1940. It is necessary, therefore, as I have said,
to regard the opinions which the persons have taken up, and to frame your argument in
accordance with the error into which each has fallen, by advancing in each discussion certain
principles and reasonable propositions, that thus, through what is agreed upon on both
sides, the truth may conclusively be brought to light. When, then, a discussion is held with
one of those who favour Greek ideas, it would be well to make the ascertaining of this the
commencement of the reasoning, i.e. whether he presupposes the existence of a God, or
concurs with the atheistic view. Should he say there is no God, then, from the consideration
of the skilful and wise economy of the Universe he will be brought to acknowledge that there
is a certain overmastering power manifested through these channels. If, on the other hand,
he should have no doubt as to the existence of Deity, but should be inclined to entertain the
presumption of a plurality of Gods, then we will adopt against him some such train of
reasoning as this: “does he think Deity is perfect or defective?” and if, as is likely, he bears
testimony to the perfection in the Divine nature, then we will demand of him to grant a
perfection throughout in everything that is observable in that divinity, in order that Deity
may not be regarded as a mixture of opposites, defect and perfection. But whether as respects
power, or the conception of goodness, or wisdom and imperishability and eternal existence,
or any other notion besides suitable to the nature of Deity, that is found to lie close to the
subject of our contemplation, in all he will agree that perfection is the idea to be entertained
of the Divine nature, as being a just inference from these premises. If this, then, be granted
1938 Sabellius. The Sabellian heresy was rife in the century preceding: i.e. that Personality is attributed to the
Deity only from the exigency of human language, that consequently He is sometimes characterized as the
Father, when operations and works more appropriate to the paternal relation are spoken of; and so in like
manner of the Son, and the Holy Ghost; as when Redemption is the subject, or Sanctification. In making the
Son the Father, it is the opposite pole to Arianism.
1939 “We see also the rise (i.e. a.d. 350) of a new and more defiant Arian school, more in earnest than the
older generation, impatient of their shuffling diplomacy, and less pliant to court influences. Aetius.…came to
rest in a clear and simple form of Arianism. Christianity without mystery seems to have been his aim. The
Anomœan leaders took their stand on the doctrine of Arius himself and dwelt with emphasis on its most offensive
aspects. Arius had long ago laid down the absolute unlikeness of the Son to the Father, but for years past the
Arianizers had prudently softened it down. Now, however, ‘unlike’ became the watchword of Aetius and Euno-
mius”: Gwatkin’s Arians. For the way in which this school treated the Trinity see Against Eunomius, p. 50.
1940 I.e.an argument against Dualism would only confirm the Jew in his stern monotheism. Manes had taught
also that “those souls who believe Jesus Christ to be the Son of God renounce the worship of the God of the
Jews, who is the Prince of Darkness,” and that “the Old Testament was the work of this Prince, who was substituted
by the Jews in the place of the true God.”
877
Prologue.