Book
III.
The two first books formed a
complete whole, but it was intimated that there might be more to come
when Jerome should have received Rufinus’ work in full. The two
first books were brought to Rufinus by the captain of a merchant-ship
trading with Aquileia, together with a copy of Jerome’s friendly
letter which had been suppressed by Pammachius. The bearer had (as
stated by Rufinus, though Jerome mocks at this as impossible) only two
days to wait. Chromatius the Bishop of Aquileia urged that the strife
should now cease, and prevailed so far as that Rufinus made no public
reply. He wrote a private letter, however, to Jerome, which has not
come down to us, and which does not seem, from the extracts given in c.
4, 6, etc., to have been of a pacific tenor. Its details may be
gathered from Jerome’s reply. Jerome intimates that it sought to
involve him in heresy, that it renewed and aggravated the former
accusations, speaking of him in language fit only for the lowest
characters on the stage; and that it declared that, if its writer had
been so minded, he could have produced facts which would have been the
destruction of his adversary. Jerome, though receiving some expressions
of the desire of Chromatius that he should not reply (perhaps also the
regretful expostulation of Augustin,—Jer. Letter cx, 6, Aug.
Letter 73) declared that it was impossible for him to yield. He could
not refrain from defending himself from a capital charge, nor could he
spare the heretics. Peace could only come by unity in the
faith.
1. Your letter is full of
falsehood and violence. I will try not to take the same
tone.
2. Why cannot we differ as
friends? Why do you, by threats of death, compel me to
answer?
3, 4. Your shameful taunt that I
wished to get copies of your Apology by bribing your Secretary is an
imputation to me of practices which are your own.
5. Eusebius should not have
accused you; but your charges against him will not stand.
6. You taunt me with boasting of
my eloquence. Will you boast of your illiteracy?
7, 8. You wish first to praise,
then to amend me, but both with fisticuffs; and make it impossible for
me to keep silence.
9. Why cannot you join with me
in condemning Origen, and so put an end to our quarrel?
10. The assertion that you had
only two days for your answer is a fiction.
11. Your translation,
contrariwise to my Commentaries, vouches for the soundness of
Origen.
12. You try to shield Origen by
falsely attributing the Apology for him to Pamphilus.
13. In my Commentaries my
quotation of opposite opinions shows that neither is mine.
14. Had you translated honestly,
you would not have had Origen’s heresies imputed to
you.
15. You say the Bishops of Italy
accept your views on the Resurrection. I doubt it.
16. You rashly say that you will
agree to whatever Theophilus lays down. You have to consider your
friendship for Isidore now his enemy.
17, 18. You speak of the
Egyptian Bishop Paul. We received him, though an Origenist, as a
stranger; and he has united himself to the orthodox faith. Not only
Theophilus but the Emperors condemn Origen.
19. Against Vigilantius I wrote
only what was right. I knew who had stirred him up against
me.
20. As to the letter of Pope
Anastasius condemning you, you will find that it is genuine.
21. Siricius who is dead may
have written in your favour; Anastasius who is living writes to the
East against you.
22. My departure from Rome for
the East had nothing blameable in it as you insinuate.
23. Epiphanius, it is true, gave
you the kiss of peace; but he showed afterwards that he had come to
distrust you.
24. When we parted as friends I
believed you a true believer; no one was sent to Rome to injure
you.
25. You swear that you did not
write my pretended retractation. Your style betrays you, and I have
given a full answer about my translations already.
26. You bid me beware of
falsification and treachery. You warn me against yourself.
27. There is nothing
inconsistent in praising a man for some things and blaming him in
others. You have done it in my case.
28–31. My ignorance of many natural phenomena is no excuse
for your ignorance as to the origin of souls. You ought, according to
your boasting dream to know everything. The thing of most importance
was forgotten in your cargo of Eastern wares.
32. Your dream was a boast: mine
of which you accuse me humbled me.
33. It was not I who first
disclosed your heresies, but Epiphanius long ago and Aterbius before
him.
34–36. As to our
translations of the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
, yours
was doing harm, and mine was necessary in self-defence. You should be
glad that heresy is exposed.
37. Your Apology for Origen did
not save him but involved you in heresy.
38. My friendly letter was to
prevent discord: the other to crush false opinions.
39, 40. Pythagoras was rightly
quoted by me. I produce some of his sayings.
41, 42. You threaten me with
destruction. I will not reply in the same way. Personalities should be
excluded from controversies of faith.
43, 44. The way of peace is
through the wisdom taught in the Book of Proverbs, and through unity in
the faith.