argument, is allowed, both premises and consequence. The premises were, that the nature of
things affords us much reason for profaning a proper respect to Christ in the heart, as a true
notion of him in the head. This he allows. What I endeavoured to infer from hence, was, that
therefore men ought to profess true piety, and not only moral sincerity: and this is also allowed
by him.
5. It appears, that the whole of my fourth argument, both premises and consequence, is
allowed. The premises were, that the Scripture reckons all visible saints who are not truly pious,
to be hypocrites. This Mr. W. expressly allows, (p. 25. e.) The consequence I inferred, was,
that visible saints are such as make a profession of true godliness, and not only moral sincer-
ity. This also is very fully allowed by him, (p. 139. a.)
6. Since it is supposed, that when Christ’s rules are attended, they that come to sacra-
ments, do not know themselves to be hypocrites, but most look at such a qualification in
themselves, as grace, and make such a pretence, and profess gospel holiness: therefore all is
in effect allowed, that I endeavoured from the latter part of the 7th chapter of Matthew,
which was to show, that professing Christians in general, all those that said, Lord, Lord, both
those that built on the sand, and those that built on a rock, were such as imagined themselves
to have a saving interest in Christ, and pretended to be his real disciples, and made such a
profession. The same was what I endeavoured to show from the parable of the ten virgins.
And therefore all that I argued from thence is in like manner allowed.
7. Hence, in vain is all the opposition Mr. W. makes to what I allege from the Acts of
the Apostles, from the story of the eunuch and other parts of that book, concerning the
manner and circumstances of the admission of members into the primitive christian church,
and the profession they made; seeing he grants the main point I endeavoured to prove by
it, viz. That they did make, and all adult persons that are admitted into the church must
make, a profession of something more than moral sincerity, even gospel-holiness.
8. Hence, in vain is all he says in opposition to my eighth argument, taken from the
manner of the apostles’ treating and addressing the primitive churches in their epistles; since
he does either expressly or virtually grant each of those three things, which he himself
reckons up as the sum of what I intend under that argument, viz. (1.) That the apostles speak
to the churches, and of them, as supposing and judging them to be gracious persons. (2.)
That the members of these churches had such an opinion of themselves. (3.) That they had
this judgment one of another. Mr. W. allows all these. He abundantly allows and asserts,
that the members of churches are such as are supposed, and rationally judged, to be gracious
persons, by those that admit them; that they are taken in under that notion, and from respect
to such a character appearing on them; and that they are rationally judged to be so by their
fellow-Christians; and that they must look at such a character in themselves, and must make
such a pretence.
1919
SECTION II. Consequences.