11. But as for you, who are not only, in common with these last, styled Donatists, from
Donatus, but also specially named Rogatists, from Rogatus, you indeed seem to be more
386
gentle in disposition, because you do not rage up and down with bands of these savage
Circumcelliones: but no wild beast is said to be gentle if, because of its not having teeth and
claws, it wounds no one. You say that you have no wish to be cruel: I think that power, not
will is wanting to you. For you are in number so few, that even if you desire it, you dare not
move against the multitudes which are opposed to you. Let us suppose, however, that you
do not wish to do that which you have not strength to do; let us suppose that the gospel
rule, “If any man will sue thee at the law and take away thy coat, let him have thy cloak
also,”2169 is so understood and obeyed by you that resistance to those who persecute you is
unlawful, whether they have right or wrong on their side. Rogatus, the founder of your sect,
either did not hold this view, or was guilty of inconsistency; for he fought with the keenest
determination in a lawsuit about certain things which, according to your statement, belonged
to you. If to him it had been said, Which of the apostles ever defended his property in a
matter concerning faith by appeal to the civil courts? as you have put the question in your
letter, “Which of the apostles ever invaded the property of other men in a matter concerning
faith?” he could not find any example of this in the Divine writings; but he might perhaps
have found some true defence if he had not separated himself from the true Church, and
then audaciously claimed to hold in the name of the true Church the disputed possession.
Chap. IV.
12. As to the obtaining or putting in force of edicts of the powers of this world against
schismatics and heretics, those from whom you separated yourselves were very active in
this matter, both against you, so far as we have heard, and against the followers of Maximi-
anus, as we prove by the indisputable evidence of their own Records; but you had not yet
separated yourselves from them at the time when in their petition they said to the Emperor
Julian that “nothing but righteousness found a place with him,”—a man whom all the while
they knew to be an apostate, and whom they saw to be so given over to idolatry, that they
must either admit idolatry to be righteousness, or be unable to deny that they had wickedly
lied when they said that nothing but righteousness had a place with him with whom they
saw that idolatry had so large a place. Grant, however, that that was a mistake in the use of
words, what say you as to the deed itself? If not even that which is just is to be sought by
appeal to an emperor, why was that which was by you supposed to be just sought from Julian?
13. Do you reply that it is lawful to petition the Emperor in order to recover what is
one’s own, but not lawful to accuse another in order that he may be coerced by the Emperor?
I may remark, in passing, that in even petitioning for the recovery of what is one’s own, the
ground covered by apostolic example is abandoned, because no apostle is found to have
2169 Matt. v. 40.
853
To Vincentius