this can be maintained, if the friend of the Count,2098 who had in the Count a god for his
companion, is said to have been in unity, and the friend of the Bridegroom to have been
excluded from it. But if John was preeminently in unity, and far more excellent and greater
than all of us and all of you, and yet the Apostle Paul baptized after him, why do you then
not baptize after Optatus? Unless indeed it be that your blindness brings you into such a
strait that you should say that Optatus had the power of giving the Holy Spirit, and that
John had not! And if you do not say this, for fear of being ridiculed for your madness even
by the insane themselves, what answer will you be able to make when you are asked why
men should have required to be baptized after receiving baptism from John, while no one
needs to be baptized after receiving it from Optatus, unless it be that the former were baptized
with the baptism of John, while, whenever any one is baptized with the baptism of Christ,
whether he be baptized by Paul or by Optatus, there is no difference in the nature of his
baptism, though there is so great a difference between Paul and Optatus? Return then, O
ye transgressors, to a right mind,2099 and do not seek to weigh the sacraments of God by
considerations of the characters and deeds of men. For the sacraments are holy through
Him to whom they belong; but when taken in hand worthily, they bring reward, when un-
worthily, judgment. And although the men are not one who take in hand the sacrament of
God worthily or unworthily, yet that which is taken in hand, whether worthily or unworthily,
is the same; so that it does not become better or worse in itself, but only turns to the life or
death of those who handle it in either case. And in respect of what you said, that "in those
whom Paul baptized after they had received the baptism of John, he washed off what had
already existed," you certainly would not have said it had you taken a moment to consider
what you were saying. For if the baptism of John required washing off, it must, beyond all
doubt, have had some foulness in it. Why then should I press you further? Recollect or
read, and see whence John received it, so shall you see against whom you have uttered that
blasphemy; and when you have discovered this, your heart will surely be beaten, if a rein be
not set on your tongue.
89. To come next to what you think you say against us with so much point: "If we do
ill in urging this, why do you seek after us?" cannot you even yet call to mind that only those
are sought after who have perished? Or is the incapacity for seeing this an element in your
ruin? For the sheep might say to the shepherd with equal absurdity, If I do wrong in straying
from the flock, why do you search after me? not understanding that the very reason why it
is being sought is because it thinks there is no need for seeking it. But who is there that
seeks for you, either through His Scriptures, or by catholic and conciliatory voices, or by
the scourgings of temporal afflictions, save only Him who dispenses that mercy to you in
2098 Gildo; see above, 23, 53.
2099 Isa. xlvi. 8.
1070
Chapter 37