Chapter 45.—54. But that neither he nor any one of you might say that, when any one
of concealed bad character is the baptizer, then he whom he baptizes is not his fruit, but the
fruit of Christ, I went on immediately to point out what a foolish error is consequent also
on that opinion; and I repeated, though in other words, what I had said shortly before: If,
when the quality of the tree is concealed, but evil, any one who may have been baptized by
it is born, not of it but of Christ, then they are justified with greater holiness who are baptized
by wicked men, whose wickedness is concealed, than they who are baptized by men that are
genuinely and manifestly good.2416 Petilianus then, being hemmed in by these embarrassing
straits, said nothing about the earlier part on which these remarks depended, and in his
answer so quoted his absurd consequence of his error as though I had stated it as my own
opinion, whereas it was really stated in order that he might perceive the amount of evil
consequent on his opinion, and so be forced to alter it. Imposing, therefore, this deceit on
those who hear and read his words, and never for a moment supposing that what we have
written could be read, he begins a vehement and petulant invective against me, as though I
had thought that all who are baptized ought to wish that they might have as their baptizers
men who are faithless, without knowing this themselves, since, however good the men might
be whom they had to baptize them, Christ is incomparably better, who will then be the head
of the person baptized, if the faithless baptizer conceal his true character. As though, too,
I had thought that those were justified with greater holiness who are baptized by evil men,
whose character is concealed, than those who are baptized by men that are genuinely and
manifestly good; when this marvellous piece of madness was only mentioned by me as fol-
lowing necessarily on the opinion of those who think with Petilianus, that a man, when
baptized, bears the same relation to his baptizer as fruit does to the tree from which it
619
springs,—good fruit springing from a good tree, evil fruit from an evil tree,—seeing that
they, when they are bidden by me to answer whose fruit they think a man that is baptized
to be when he is baptized by one of secretly bad character, since they do not venture to re-
baptize him, are compelled to answer, that then he is not the fruit of that man of secretly
bad character, but that he is the fruit of Christ. And so they are followed by a consequence
contrary to their inclination, which none but a madman would entertain,—that if a man is
the fruit of his baptizer when he is baptized by one that is genuinely and manifestly good,
but when he is baptized by one of secretly bad character, he is then not his fruit, but the
fruit of Christ,—it cannot but follow that they are justified with greater holiness who are
baptized by men of secretly bad character, than those who are baptized by men who are
genuinely and manifestly good.
2416 See Book I. cc. 7, 8, 8, 9.
Chapter 45
1233
Chapter 45