The
Apology of Rufinus.
Addressed to Apronianus, in
Reply to Jerome’s Letter to Pammachius,
2814
Written at Aquileia
a.d.
400.
————————————
In Two Books.
————————————
In order to understand the
controversy between Jerome and Rufinus it is necessary to look back
over their earlier relations. They had been close friends in early
youth (Jerome, Ep. iii, 3, v, 2.) and had together formed part of a
society of young Christian ascetics at Aquileia in the years
370–3. Jerome’s letter (3) to Rufinus in 374 is full of
affection; in 381 he was placed in Jerome’s Chronicle (year 378)
as “a monk of great renown,” and when after some years,
they were neighbours in Palestine, Rufinus with Melania on the Mt. of
Olives, Jerome with Paula at Bethlehem, they remained friends. (Ruf.
Apol. ii. 8 (2).) In the disputes about Origenism which arose from the
visits of Aterbius (Jer. Apol. iii, 33) and Epiphanius (Jerome Against
John of Jerusalem, 11), they became estranged, Jerome siding with
Epiphanius and Rufinus with John (Jer Letter li, 6. Against John of
Jerusalem II). They were reconciled before Rufinus left Palestine in
397 (Jer. Apol. i, 1, iii, 33). But when Rufinus came to Italy and at
the request of Macarius
2815
translated
Origen’s
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
, the
Preface which he prefixed to this work was the occasion for a fresh and
final outbreak of dissension. The friends of Jerome of whom Pammachius,
Oceanus and Marcella were the most prominent, were scandalized at some
of the statements of the book, and still more at the assumption made by
Rufinus that Jerome, by his previous translations of some of
Origen’s works, had proved himself his admirer. They also
suspected that Rufinus’ translation had made Origen speak in an
orthodox sense which was not genuine and that heterodox statements had
been suppressed. They therefore wrote to Jerome at Bethlehem a letter
(translated among Jerome’s letters in this Series No. lxxxiii)
begging for information on all these points. Jerome in reply made a
literal translation of the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
, and
sent it accompanied by a letter (lxxxiv) in which he declared that he
had never been a partisan of Origen’s dogmatic system, though he
admired him as a commentator. He fastened on some of the most
questionable of Origen’s speculations, his doctrine of the
resurrection, of the previous existence of souls and their fall into
human bodies, and the ultimate restoration of all spiritual beings; his
permission, in agreement with Plato, of the use of falsehood in certain
cases; and some expressions about the relation of the Persons of the
Godhead which, at least to Western ears, seemed a denial of their
equality. He appealed to his own commentaries on Ecclesiastes and on
the Ephesians to show that he rejected these doctrines; and he urged
that, even if he had once had too indiscriminate an admiration of
Origen, he had in later years judged more clearly.
In the main Jerome’s
defence was valid. But it demanded considerateness in his judges; and
this quality was absent in himself. He judged Origen’s opinions
harshly, and spoke of his views as poisonous (Letter lxxxiv, 3); and,
when we contrast the lenity of his former judgments on the same points
with his present violence, it becomes evident that he was more
concerned for his own reputation than for truth. Rufinus charges him
(Apol. i. c. 23 to 44) with maintaining, in his Commentaries on the
Ephesians (written twelve years earlier in 388) to which Jerome had
appealed (Ep. lxxxiv, 2) the views which he now denounced; and the
charge, though urged too far, is substantially made out. The opinions
of Origen which he introduced into this Commentary about the fall of
souls out of a previous state of bliss into human bodies are set down
with hardly a word of objection (comm. on ch. i, v. 4), and his
speculations on the Powers and Principalities of the world to come (ib.
v. 21) and on the rise of Lucifer and his angels to be subjects of
Christ’s Kingdom (id. ii, 7) and their part in the final
restoration of all things (id. iv, 16) are adopted as his own, thus
giving some justification for Rufinus’ attack (Apol. i,
34–36. &c.). His defence of himself therefore is hardly
candid. And his allusions to his opponent are exasperating, e.g. when
he speaks (Letter lxxxiv, 1) of some persons “who love me so well
that they cannot be heretics without me.” “I wonder that,
while they speak in detraction of the flesh, they live carnally and
thus cherish and nourish delicately their enemy” (Id. 8). He
hardly argues fairly as to Rufinus’ assertion that Origen’s
works had suffered from falsification: and he is carried so far by his
animosity that he denies the Apology of Pamphilus for Origen to be by
Pamphilus, though he had himself attributed it to him (De Vir. Ill. c.
7. 5) and no one can doubt that it is his. (See Dict. of Christ. Biog.
Art. Pamphilus.)
But though writing thus for his
friends generally, Jerome wrote at the same time a friendly letter to
Rufinus himself in answer, it would seem, to one from him, (Letter
lxxxi.) in which he speaks of their common friends, and of the death of
Rufinus’ mother, and says that he has charged a friend whom he is
sending to Italy to visit Rufinus and assure him of his high esteem;
and, while remonstrating with him for his Preface to the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
, merely
says “I have begged my other friends to avoid a quarrel. I count
on your sense of equity not to give occasion to impatient persons; for
you will not find every one, like me, able to take pleasure in praises
framed to suit a purpose.”
2816
Had this letter reached Rufinus,
the ensuing controversy would have been avoided. But it never reached
him. It was sent through Pammachius, and he and Jerome’s other
friends kept it back, while they published the letter sent them with
Jerome’s translation of the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
. Rufinus
who was now at Aquileia, having left Rome probably early in 399 wrote
the Apology, addressing it to his friend and convert Apronianus at
Rome.
2814
Ep. 84.
2815
See the Translation of Rufinus’ Prefaces given above, and
the notes prefixed to them.
2816
Or Feigned praises—figuratis laudibus.