Chapter XXVIII.—A
Curious Inconsistency in Hermogenes Exposed. Certain
Expressions in The History of Creation Vindicated in
The True Sense.
But we shall show not only that this
condition
6392
agreed with this
earth of ours, but that
it did not agree with that other
(insisted on by Hermogenes). For, inasmuch as pure Matter was thus
subsistent with God,
6393
without the
interposition indeed of any element at all (because as yet there
existed nothing but itself and God), it could not of course have been
invisible. Because, although
Hermogenes
contends that darkness
was inherent in the substance of Matter, a position which we shall have
to meet in its proper place,
6394
yet darkness is
visible even to a human being (for the very fact that there is the
darkness is an evident one), much more is it so to God. If indeed
it
6395
had been invisible, its quality would not
have been by any means discoverable. How, then, did Hermogenes find
out
6396
that that substance was “without
form,” and confused and disordered, which, as being invisible,
was not palpable to his senses? If this mystery was revealed to him by
God, he ought to give us his proof. I want to know also, whether (the
substance in question) could have been described as “void.”
That certainly is “void” which is imperfect. Equally
certain is it, that nothing can be imperfect but that which is made; it
is imperfect when it is not fully made.
6397
Certainly, you admit. Matter, therefore, which was not made at all,
could not have been imperfect; and what was not imperfect was not
“void.” Having no beginning, because it was not made, it
was also unsusceptible of any void-condition.
6398
For this void-condition is an accident of beginning. The earth, on the
contrary, which was made, was deservedly called
“void.” For as soon as it was made, it had the
condition of being imperfect, previous to its
completion.
6392
Habitum.
6393
Deo subjacebat.
6394
See below, ch. xxx. p.
494.
6395
Matter.
6396
“Compertus
est” is here a deponent verb.
6397
Minus factum.
6398
Rudimento. Tertullian
uses the word “rudis” (unformed) for the scriptural term
(“void”); of this word “rudimentum” is the
abstract.