another objection remains, viz., that both Socrates and Sozomen say that the creeds were
drawn up after the deposition of Athanasius, “and yet” (as Hefele remarks, Vol. II., p. 63),
“St. Hilary says that these creeds proceeded from a ‘Synod of Saints.’”
Schelstraten’s hypothesis not being satisfactory, the learned Ballerini, in their appendix
to the Opera S. Leonis M., have set forth another theory with which Mansi agrees in his
“Notes on Alexander Natalis’s Church History.” These maintain that the canons did not
come from the Council in Encæniis at all, but from another synod held before, in 332; but
Hefele rejects this hypothesis altogether, on the following grounds. First and chiefest because
it has no external evidence to support it; and secondly because the internal evidence is most
unsatisfactory. But even if the 25 canons were adopted by a synod at Antioch in 332, the
106
real difficulty would not be obviated, for Socrates says164 of that synod that there too the
“opposers of the Nicene faith” were able to elect their candidate to fill the place of the ban-
ished bishop Eustathius!
Hefele seems to give the true solution of the whole difficulty when he says: “Certainly
Athanasius identified the Eusebians with the Arians and we regard them as at least Semi-
arians; but at that time, after they had made the orthodox confession of faith, and repeatedly
declared their disapproval of the heresies condemned at Nice, they were considered, by the
greater number, as lawful bishops, and thoroughly orthodox and saintly men might without
hesitation unite with them at a synod.”165
Pope Julius styles the very Eusebian synod that deposed Athanasius “dear brethren”
while blaming their action, and invited them to a common synod to enquire into the charges
made against the Saint. In view of all this we may well believe that both orthodox and Eu-
sebians met together at the consecration of the Emperor’s new church, and that the whole
church afterwards awarded the canons then adopted a rank in accordance with their intrinsic
worth, and without any regard to the motives or shades of theological opinion that swayed
those who drafted and voted for them.
164 Socrates. H. E., Lib. I., Cap. xxiv.
165 Hefele. History of the Councils. Vol. II., p. 66. I have in this introduction done little more than condense
Hefele.
211
Historical Introduction.