erroneous views on the nature of the soul, the limitation of future punishment, and the
lawfulness of fraud for supposed good purposes.
3. The anti-Donatistic works, composed between the years 393 and 420, argue against
separatism, and contain Augustin’s doctrine of the church and church-discipline, and of
the sacraments. To these belong: Psalmus contra partem Donati (A.D. 393), a polemic
popular song without regular metre, intended to offset the songs of the Donatists; Contra
epistolam Parmeniani, written in 400 against the Carthaginian bishop of the Donatists, the
successor of Donatus; De baptismo contra Donastistas, in favor of the validity of heretical
baptism (400); Contra literas Petiliani (about 400), against the view of Cyprian and the
Donatists, that the efficacy of the sacraments depends on the personal worthiness and the
ecclesiastical status of the officiating priest; Ad Catholicos Epistola contra Donatistas, or De
unitate ecclesiæ (402); Contra Cresconium grammaticum Donastistam (406); Breviculus
Collationis cum Donatistis, a short account of the three days’ religious conference with the
Donatists (411); De correctione Donatistarum(417); Contra Gaudentium, Donat. Episcopum,
the last anti-Donatistic work (420).48
These works are the chief patristic authority of the Roman Catholic doctrine of the
church and against the sects. They are thoroughly Romanizing in spirit and aim, and least
satisfactory to Protestant readers. Augustin defended in his later years even the principle of
17
forcible coërcion and persecution against heretics and schismatics by a false exegesis of the
words in the parable “Compel them to come in” (Luke xiv. 23). The result of persecution
was that both Catholics and Donatists in North Africa were overwhelmed in ruin first by
the barbarous Vandals, who were Arian heretics, and afterwards by the Mohammedan
conquerors.
4. The anti-Arian works have to do with the deity of Christ and of the Holy Spirit, and
with the Holy Trinity. By far the most important of these are the fifteen books De Trinitate
(400-416);—the most profound and discriminating production of the ancient church on
the Trinity, in no respect inferior to the kindred works of Athanasius and the two Gregories,
and for centuries final to the dogma.49 This may also be counted among the positive didactic
works, for it is not directly controversial. The Collatio cum Maximino Ariano, an obscure
babbler, belongs to the year 428.
5. The numerous anti-Pelagian works of Augustin are his most influential and most
valuable, at least for Protestants. They were written between the years 412 and 429. In them
Augustin, in his intellectual and spiritual prime, develops his system of anthropology and
48 All these in tom. ix. Comp. Church Hist. III. §§69 and 70.
49 Tom. viii. ed Bened. p. 749 sqq. Comp. Ch. Hist. III §131. The work was stolen from him by some impatient
friends before revision, and before the completion of the twelfth book, so that he became much discouraged,
and could only be moved to finish it by urgent entreaties.
35
The Writings of St. Augustin