Chapter 7.—That the Suggestions of Philosophers are Precluded from Having Any
Moral Effect, Because They Have Not the Authority Which Belongs to Divine Instruction,
and Because Man’s Natural Bias to Evil Induces Him Rather to Follow the Examples of the
Gods Than to Obey the Precepts of Men.
But will they perhaps remind us of the schools of the philosophers, and their disputa-
tions? In the first place, these belong not to Rome, but to Greece; and even if we yield to
them that they are now Roman, because Greece itself has become a Roman province, still
the teachings of the philosophers are not the commandments of the gods, but the discoveries
of men, who, at the prompting of their own speculative ability, made efforts to discover the
hidden laws of nature, and the right and wrong in ethics, and in dialectic what was consequent
according to the rules of logic, and what was inconsequent and erroneous. And some of
them, by God’s help, made great discoveries; but when left to themselves they were betrayed
by human infirmity, and fell into mistakes. And this was ordered by divine providence,
that their pride might be restrained, and that by their example it might be pointed out that
it is humility which has access to the highest regions. But of this we shall have more to say,
if the Lord God of truth permit, in its own place.97 However, if the philosophers have made
any discoveries which are sufficient to guide men to virtue and blessedness, would it not
have been greater justice to vote divine honors to them? Were it not more accordant with
every virtuous sentiment to read Plato’s writings in a “Temple of Plato,” than to be present
in the temples of devils to witness the priests of Cybele98 mutilating themselves, the effem-
inate being consecrated, the raving fanatics cutting themselves, and whatever other cruel
or shameful, or shamefully cruel or cruelly shameful, ceremony is enjoined by the ritual of
27
such gods as these? Were it not a more suitable education, and more likely to prompt the
youth to virtue, if they heard public recitals of the laws of the gods, instead of the vain
laudation of the customs and laws of their ancestors? Certainly all the worshippers of the
Roman gods, when once they are possessed by what Persius calls “the burning poison of
lust,”99 prefer to witness the deeds of Jupiter rather than to hear what Plato taught or Cato
censured. Hence the young profligate in Terence, when he sees on the wall a fresco repres-
enting the fabled descent of Jupiter into the lap of Danaë in the form of a golden shower,
accepts this as authoritative precedent for his own licentiousness, and boasts that he is an
97 See below, books viii.-xii.
98 “Galli,” the castrated priests of Cybele, who were named after the river Gallus, in Phrygia, the water of
which was supposed to intoxicate or madden those who drank it. According to Vitruvius (viii. 3), there was a
similar fountain in Paphlagonia. Apuleius (Golden Ass, viii.) gives a graphic and humorous description of the
dress, dancing and imposture of these priests; mentioning, among other things, that they lashed themselves with
whips and cut themselves with knives till the ground was wet with blood.
99 Persius, Sat. iii. 37.
That the Suggestions of Philosophers are Precluded from Having Any Moral Effect, Because They Have Not the Authority Which Belongs to Divine Instruction, and Because Man’s Natural Bias to Evil Induces Him Rather to Follow the Examples of the Gods Than to Obey the Precepts of Men.
76
That the Suggestions of Philosophers are Precluded from Having Any Moral…