Book vr.] ARNOBIUS ADVERSUS GENTES. 907
The pestilences and other calamities are next discussed, which were
supposed to have been sent by the gods as punishments for sacrifices
or other honours withheld from them (38). Thus it was related that,
the ludi Circenses having been violated, a pestilence ensued until they
were once more celebrated in due form (39). Other pestilences also were
got rid of, and enemies overcome, when gods had been brought across
the seas and established at Rome; while, on the Capitol’s being struck by
lightning, evil was averted only by rearing towards the east an image
of Jupiter in a higher place (40). But how can the story of the ludi
Circenses be believed, which represents Jupiter as delighting in childish
amusements, angry without cause, and punishing those who had done
no wrong (41, 42), and going so far astray in making choice of a man
to declare the cause of his anger (48)? In like manner Arnobius dis-
cusses the transportation of /Esculapius, in the form of a serpent, from
Epidaurus to the island in the Tiber, after which it was said the people
were restored to health (44-46). In reply to the question how it was
that the plague ceased if the god did not really come to Rome, Arno-
bius asks how it was that, if the god did come to Rome, he did not
preserve the city from all disease and pestilence thereafter (47) ; and as
to the argument, that this did not happen because in later ages wicked-
ness and impiety prevailed, reminds his opponent that at no epoch was
Rome a city of the good and pious (48). So, too, the Great Mother
was said to have been brought from Phrygia to enable the Romans to
overcome Hannibal. But all that was brought was a stone (49); and
are we to suppose that Hannibal was overcome by a stone, and not by
the energy, resolution, and courage of the Romans? But if the Great
Mother really drove Hannibal from Italy, why did she delay doing so
until carried over the seas to Rome (50)? But without insisting on
these objections, who will call her a goddess who is perfectly capri-
cious, abandons her worshippers to settle amongst those who are more
powerful, and loves to be in the midst of slaughter and bloodshed,
whilst the true gods must be perfectly just and equally well disposed to
all men (51)?
a GAIA LLAT, then,’ some one will say, do you think
| that no sacrifices at all should be offered ?
To answer you not with our own, but with
your Varro’s opinion—none. Why so? Be-
. cause, he says, the true gods neither wish nor demand these;
1 If this seems rather an abrupt beginning, it must be remembered
that by some accident the introduction to the seventh book has been
tacked on as a last chapter to the sixth, where it is just as out of place
as here it would be in keeping.