on the increase, that of the νόθοι on the decrease, and already he could draw a sharp distinction between them,
as Clement of Alexandria could not do a century before. The distinction drawn has no relation to the authenticity
or original authority of the works of the two classes, but only to their canonicity or uncanonicity at the time
Eusebius wrote. This interpretation will help us to understand the peculiar way in which Eusebius treats the
Apocalypse, and thus his treatment of it becomes an argument in favor of the interpretation. He puts it, first
among the Homologoumena with an εἴγε φανείη, and then among the νόθοι with an εἴ φανείη. No one, so far
as I know, has explained why it should be put among the νόθοι as an alternative to the Homologoumena, instead
of among the Antilegomena,which, on the common interpretation of the relation of the classes, might be naturally
expected. If the view presented is correct, the reason is clear. The Antilegomena were those works which had
been disputed, but were becoming more and more widely accepted as canonical. The Apocalypse could not
under any circumstances fall into this class, for the doubts raised against it in the orthodox Church were of recent
date. It occupied, in fact, a peculiar position, for there was no other work which, while accepted as canonical,
was doubted in the present more than in the past. Eusebius then must either put it into a special class or put it
conditionally into two different classes, as he does. If the doubts should become so widespread as to destroy its
canonicity, it would fall naturally into the νόθοι, for then it would hold the same position as the other works of
that class. As an historian, Eusebius sees the tendency and undoubtedly has the idea that the Apocalypse may
eventually, like the other Christian works of the same class (the Shepherd, the Apocalypse of Peter, etc.), become
one of the νόθοι, one of the works which, formerly accepted, is at length commonly denied to be canonical: and
so, as an historian, he presents the alternative. The Apocalypse was the only work in regard to which any doubt
could exist. Eusebius’ failure to mention explicitly in this passage the Epistle to the Hebrews, has caused consid-
erable misunderstanding. The explanation, if the view presented be adopted, is simple. Eusebius included it, I
believe, among the epistles of Paul, and did not especially mention it, simply because there was no dispute about
its canonicity. Its Pauline authorship had been widely disputed as Eusebius informs us elsewhere, and various
theories had been proposed to account for it; but its canonicity had not been doubted in the orthodox Church,
and therefore doubts as to the authorship of it did not in the least endanger its place among the Homologoumena,
as used here in a technical sense; and since Eusebius was simply stating the works of each class, not discussing
the nature and origin of those works, he could, in perfect fairness, include it in Paul’s epistles (where he himself
believed it belonged) without entering upon any discussion of it. Another noticeable omission is that of the
Epistle of Clement to the Corinthians. All efforts to find a satisfactory reason for this are fruitless. It should have
been placed among the νόθοι with the Epistle of Barnabas, etc., as Eusebius’ treatment of it in other passages
shows. It must be assumed, with Holtzmann, that the omission of it was nothing more nor less than an oversight.
Eusebius, then, classifies the works mentioned in this chapter upon two principles: first, in relation to canonicity,
into the canonical and the uncanonical; and secondly, in relation to character, into the orthodox (Homologoumena,
Antilegomena, which are canonical, and νόθοι, which are uncanonical), and heterodox (which are not, and
never have been, canonical, never have been accepted as of use or authority). The Homologoumena and Antileg-
omena, then, are both canonical and orthodox, the ἀναπλ€σματα αἱρετικῶν ἀνδρῶν are neither canonical nor
orthodox, while the νόθοι occupy a peculiar position, being orthodox but not canonical. The last-named are
much more closely related to the canonical than to the heterodox works, because when the canon was a less
concrete and exact thing than it had at length become, they were associated with the other orthodox works as,
322
The Divine Scriptures that are accepted and those that are not.