had formerly established, but made for themselves laws according to their own purpose, as
each one desired, and observed them, and thus assembled as separate congregations in
various places.
8. When we had issued this decree that they should return to the institutions established
by the ancients,2595 a great many2596 submitted under danger, but a great many being har-
assed endured all kinds of death.2597
their separation from their heathen fellow-citizens in matters of life and worship as a rebuke to them for their
departure from the original unity of the Christian Church. Again, in the next sentence the “institutions of the
ancients” (veterum instituta) are referred to in the most general way, without any such qualification as could
possibly lead the Christians or any one else to think that the institutions of the Christian religion were meant.
Conformity to “the ancient laws and public discipline of the Romans” is announced in the beginning of the edict
as the object which Galerius had in view. Could he admit, even for the sake of propitiating his Christian subjects,
that those laws and that discipline were Christian? Veterum instituta in fact could mean to the reader nothing
else, as thus absolutely used, than the institutions of the old Romans. Still further it is to be noticed that in §9
Galerius does not say “but although many persevere in their purpose…nevertheless, in consideration of our
philanthropy, we have determined that we ought to extend our indulgence,” &c., but rather “and since (atque
cum) many persevere in their purpose,” &c. The significance of this has apparently been hitherto quite overlooked.
Does he mean to say that he feels that he ought to extend indulgence just because they do exactly what they did
before—worship neither the gods of the heathen nor the God of the Christians? I can hardly think so. He seems
to me to say rather, “Since many, in spite of my severe measures, still persevere in their purpose (in proposito
perseverarent) and refuse to worship our gods, while at the same time they cease under the pressure to worship
their own God as they have been accustomed to do, I have decided to permit them to return to their own worship,
thinking it better that they worship the God of the Christians than that they worship no God; provided in wor-
shiping him they do nothing contrary to discipline (contra disciplinam), i.e. contrary to Roman law.” Thus in-
terpreted, the entire edict seems to me consistent and at the same time perfectly natural. It is intended to propi-
tiate the Christians and to have them pray for the good of the emperor to their own God, rather than refuse to
pray for him altogether. It is not an acknowledgment even to the Christians that their God is the supreme and
only true God, but it is an acknowledgment that their God is probably better than no god, and that the empire
will be better off if they become loyal, peaceable, prayerful citizens again (even if their prayers are not directed
to the highest gods), than if they continue disaffected and disloyal and serve and worship no superior being.
That the edict becomes, when thus interpreted, much more dignified and much more worthy of an emperor
cannot be denied; and, little respect as we may have for Galerius, we should not accuse him of playing the hypocrite
and the fool in this matter, except on better grounds than are offered by the extant text of this edict.
2595 ἐπὶ τὰ ὑπὸ τῶν ἀρχαὶων καταστ€θεντα. Latin: ad veterum instituta.
2596 πλεῖστοι. Latin: multi.
2597 παντοίους θαν€τους ὑπέφερον. Latin: deturbati sunt.
875
The Revocation of the Rulers.