Church, and that nevertheless the Church did not perish, but remained in the dignity be-
longing to her nature as the Lord’s wheat scattered throughout the world. And, therefore,
if in your consternation you thus betake yourselves to Cyprian’s authority as to a harbour
of refuge, you see the rock against which your error dashes itself in this course; if, on the
other hand, you do not venture to flee thither, you are wrecked without any struggle for
escape.
40. Moreover, Cyprian either did not hold at all the opinions which you ascribe to him,
or did subsequently correct his mistake by the rule of truth, or covered this blemish, as we
may call it, upon his otherwise spotless mind by the abundance of his love, in his most amply
defending the unity of the Church growing throughout the whole world, and in his most
stedfastly holding the bond of peace; for it is written, “Charity [love] covereth a multitude
of sins.”2257 To this was also added, that in him, as a most fruitful branch, the Father removed
by the pruning-knife of suffering whatever may have remained in him requiring correction:
“For every branch in me,” saith the Lord, “that beareth fruit He purgeth, that it may bring
forth more fruit.”2258 And whence this care of him, if not because, continuing as a branch
in the far-spreading vine, he did not forsake the root of unity? “For though he gave his body
to be burned, if he had not charity, it would profit him nothing.”2259
41. Attend now a little while to the letters of Cyprian, that you may see how he proves
the man to be inexcusable who desires ostensibly on the ground of his own righteousness
to withdraw himself from the unity of the Church (which God promised and has fulfilled
in all nations), and that you may more clearly apprehend the truth of the text quoted by me
shortly before: “There is a generation that esteem themselves righteous, and have not cleansed
themselves from the guilt of their going forth.” In a letter which he wrote to Antonianus2260
he discusses a matter very closely akin to that which we are now debating; but it is better
for us to give his very words: “Some of our predecessors,” he says, “in the episcopal office
in this province were of opinion that the peace of the Church should not be given to fornic-
ators, and finally closed the door of repentance against those who had been guilty of adultery.
They did not, however, withdraw themselves from fellowship with their colleagues in the
episcopate; nor did they rend asunder the unity of the Catholic Church, by such harshness
and obstinate perseverance in their censure as to separate themselves from the Church be-
cause others granted while they themselves refused to adulterers the peace of the Church.
The bond of concord remaining unbroken, and the sacrament of the Church continuing
undivided, each bishop arranges and orders his own conduct as one who shall give account
2257 1 Pet. iv. 8.
2258 John xv. 2.
2259 1 Cor. xiii. 3.
2260 Letter LI. 21. Ante-Nicene Fathers, Am. ed. vol. v. p. 332.
872
To Vincentius