OBJECT. I.
The Scripture calls the members of the visible church by the name of disciples, scholars,
or learners: and that suggests to us this notion of the visible church, that it is the school of
Christ, into which persons are admitted in order to their learning of Christ, and coming to
spiritual attainments, in the use of the means of teaching, discipline, and training up, estab-
lished in the school. Now if this be a right notion of the visible church, then reason shows
that no other qualifications are necessary in order to being members of this school, than
such a faith and disposition of mind as are requisite to persons’ putting themselves under
Christ as their Master and Teacher, and subjecting themselves to the orders of the school.
But a common faith and moral sincerity are sufficient for this.—Therefore the Scripture leads
us to suppose the visible church to be properly constituted of those who have these qualific-
ations, though they have not saving faith and true piety.
Answer 1. I own, the Scripture calls the members of the visible church by the name of
disciple; but deny, that it therefore follows that the church of which they are members, is
duly and properly constituted of those who have not true piety. Because, if this consequence
was good, then it would equally follow, that not only the visible, but also the invisible or
mystical, church is properly constituted of those who have not unfeigned faith and true
461
piety. For the members of the mystical church, as such, and to denote the special character
of such, are called disciples; Luke xiv. 26, 27, 33.. and John viii. 31; xiii. 35; xv. 8.. This shows,
that in the argument I am answering, there is no connexion between the premises and the
conclusion. For the force of the objection consists in this, that the members of the visible
church are called disciples in Scripture: this is the sum total of the premises: and if there be
any connexion between the premises and the conclusion, it must lie in the truth of this
proposition; The church whose members are called by the name of disciples, as signifying
their state and quality as members of that society, that church is properly and fitly constituted,
not only of persons truly pious, but of others that have merely a common faith and virtue. But
this proposition, we have seen, is not true; and so there is no connexion between the former
and latter part of it, which are the same with the premises and conclusion of this argument.
2. Though I do not deny, that the visible church of Christ may fitly be represented as a
school of Christ, where persons are trained up in the use of means, in order to some spiritual
attainments: yet it will not hence necessarily follow, that this is in order to all good attain-
ments; for it will not follow but that certain good attainments may be prerequisite, in order
to a place in the school. The church of Christ is a school appointed for the training up Christ’s
little children, to greater degrees of knowledge, higher privileges, and greater serviceableness
in this world, and more meetness for the possession of their eternal inheritance. But there
is no necessity of supposing, that it is in order to fit them to become Christ’s children, or to
be introduced into his family; any more than there is a necessity of supposing, because a
prince puts his children under tutors, that therefore it must be in order to their being of the
OBJ. I. The churchy is the school of Christ.
1822
OBJ. I. The churchy is the school of Christ.