Book vi] ARNOBIUS ADVERSUS GENTES. 949
see all the things which are offered to them consumed here
under our eyes, what else can be said to reach them from us
than opinions worthy of the gods, and most appropriate to
their name? These are the surest gifts, these true sacri-
fices; for gruel, incense, and flesh feed the devouring flames,
and agree very well with the parentalia* of the dead.
38. If the immortal gods cannot be angry, says [my
opponent] and their nature is not agitated or troubled by
any passions, what do the histories, the annals mean, in
which we find it written? that the gods, moved by some
annoyances, occasioned pestilences, sterility,* failure of crops,
and other dangers, to states and nations; and that they
again, being appeased and satisfied by means of? sacrifices,
laid aside their burning anger, and changed the state of the
atmosphere and times into a happier one? What [is the
meaning of] the earth’s roarings, the earthquakes, which we
have been told occurred because the games had been cele-
brated carelessly, and their nature and circumstances [had]
not been attended to, and yet, on their being celebrated
afresh, and repeated with assiduous care, the terrors of the
gods were stilled, and [they] were recalled to care and friend-
ship for men? How often, after that—in obedience to the
commands of the seers and the responses of the diviners—
sacrifice has been offered, and certain gods have been sum-
moned from nations dwelling beyond the sea, and shrines
erected to them, and certain images and statues set on loftier
pillars, have fears of impending dangers been diverted, and
the most troublesome enemies beaten, and the republic ex-
tended both by repeated joyous victories, and by gaining
possession of several provinces! Now, certainly this would
not happen if the gods despised sacrifices, games, and other
acts of worship, and did not consider themselves honoured
by expiatory offerings. If, then, all the rage and indignation
of the deities are cooled when these things are offered, and
1 j.e. offerings to parents, as the name implies, and other relatives who
were dead.
2 35 in Orelli. 3 Lit., * in the writings of which we read.”
FL > Lit., * by satisfaction of."