Chapter 12.—18. What if he approached baptism itself in deceit? were his sins remitted,
or were they not? Let them choose which they will. Whichever they choose will answer our
purpose. If they say they were remitted, how then shall "the Holy Spirit of discipline flee
deceit,"1184 if in him who was full of deceit He worked remission of sins? If they say they
were not remitted, I ask whether, if he should afterwards confess his sin with contrition of
heart and true sorrow, it would be judged that he ought to be baptized again. And if it is
mere madness to assert this, then let them confess that a man can be baptized with the true
baptism of Christ, and that yet his heart, persisting in malice or sacrilege, may not allow
remission of sins to be given; and so let them understand that men may be baptized in
communions severed from the Church, in which Christ’s baptism is given and received in
the said celebration of the sacrament, but that it will only then be of avail for the remission
of sins, when the recipient, being reconciled to the unity of the Church, is purged from the
sacrilege of deceit, by which his sins were retained, and their remission prevented. For, as
in the case of him who had approached the sacrament in deceit there is no second baptism,
but he is purged by faithful discipline and truthful confession, which he could not be without
baptism, so that what was given before becomes then powerful to work his salvation, when
the former deceit is done away by the truthful confession; so also in the case of the man
who, while an enemy to the peace and love of Christ, received in any heresy or schism the
baptism of Christ, which the schismatics in question had not lost from among them, though
by his sacrilege his sins were not remitted, yet, when he corrects his error, and comes over
to the communion and unity of the Church, he ought not to be again baptized: because by
his very reconciliation to the peace of the Church he receives this benefit, that the sacrament
now begins in unity to be of avail for the remission of his sins, which could not so avail him
as received in schism.
19. But if they should say that in the man who has approached the sacrament in deceit,
his sins are indeed removed by the holy power of so great a sacrament at the moment when
he received it, but return immediately in consequence of his deceit: so that the Holy Spirit
has both been present with him at his baptism for the removal of his sins, and has also fled
before his perseverance in deceit so that they should return: so that both declarations prove
true,—both, "As many of you as have been baptized into Christ have put on Christ;" and
also, "The holy spirit of discipline will flee deceit;"—that is to say, that both the holiness of
420
baptism clothes him with Christ, and the sinfulness of deceit strips him of Christ; like the
case of a man who passes from darkness through light into darkness again, his eyes being
always directed towards darkness, though the light cannot but penetrate them as he passes;—if
they should say this, let them understand that this is also the case with those who are baptized
without the pale of the Church, but yet with the baptism of the Church, which is holy in itself,
1184 Wisd. i. 5.
Chapter 12
716
Chapter 12