how mankind came into America, and there had anciently been a ship of the Phoenicians
wrecked at sea, and a single man of the crew was driven on this continent, and here died as
soon as he reached the shore—it should be said, By that one man mankind came into
America.
Besides, it is not true, that by one man, or by Adam, sin entered into the world, in Dr.
T.’s sense: for it was not he but Eve that began transgression. By one man Dr. T. understands
Adam, as the figure of Christ. And it is plain, that it was for his transgression, and not Eve’s,
that the sentence of death was pronounced on mankind after the fall, Gen. iii. 19. It appears
unreasonable to suppose the apostle means to include Eve, when he speaks of Adam; for he
lays great stress on it, that it was BY ONE, repeating it several times.
III. In like manner this author brings to nothing the sense of the causal particles, in such
phrases as these, so often repeated, Rom. v. 12 “Death by sin,” Rom. v. 15 “If through the
offence of one, many be dead,” Rom. v. 16 ”by one that sinned,—judgment was by one to
condemnation,” Rom. v. 17 ”By one man’s offence, death reigned by one,” Rom. v. 18 ”By
the offence of one, judgment came upon all,” &c., Rom. v. 19 ”By one man’s disobedience.”
These causal particles, so variously repeated, unless we make mere nonsense of the discourse,
signify some connexion and dependence, by some sort of influence of that sin of one man,
or some tendency to that effect, which is so often said to come by it. But according to Dr.
T. there can be no real dependence or influence in the case, of any sort whatsoever. There
is no connexion by any natural influence of that one act to make all mankind mortal. Our
author does not pretend to account for this effect in any such manner, but in another most
diverse, viz. A gracious act of God, laying mankind under affliction, toil, and death, from
special favour and kindness. Nor can there be any dependence of this effect on that trans-
gression of Adam, by any moral influence, as deserving such a consequence, or exposing to
it on any moral account: for he supposes, that mankind are not in this way exposed to the
least degree of evil. Nor has this effect any legal dependence on that sin, or any connexion
by virtue of any antecedent constitution, which God had established with Adam: for he insists,
that in that threatening, “In the day thou eatest thou shalt die,” there is not a word said of
his posterity (p. 8). And death on mankind, according to him, cannot come by virtue of that
legal constitution with Adam; because the sentence by which it came was after the annulling
and abolishing that constitution (p. 113. S.) And it is manifest, that this consequence cannot
be through any kind of tendency of that sin to such an effect; because the effect comes only
as a benefit, and is the fruit of mere favour: but sin has no tendency, either natural or moral,
to benefits, and divine favours. And thus that sin of Adam could neither be the efficient
cause, nor the procuring cause; neither the natural, moral, nor legal cause; nor an exciting
1089
SECTION I. Remarks on Dr. Taylor's way of explaining this text.