is a great deal of difference between these two things, viz. its being the duty of a man, who
is without spiritual light or sight, to believe, and its being his duty to believe without spiritual
light or sight, or to believe while he yet remains without spiritual light or sight. Just the same
difference, which there is between these two things, viz. its being his duty who has no faith
to believe, and its being his duty to believe without faith, or to believe without believing. I
trust none will assert the latter, because of the contradiction which it implies. As it is not
proper to say, it is a man’s duty to believe without faith, because it implies a contradiction;
so I think it equally improper to say, it is a man’s duty to believe without those things which
are essentially implied in faith, because that also implies a contradiction. But a spiritual sight
of Christ, or knowledge of Christ, is essentially implied in the very nature and notion of
faith; and therefore it is absurd to talk of believing on Christ, without spiritual light or sight.
It is the duty of a man, who is without those things which essentially belong to faith, to be-
lieve; and it is the duty of a man, who is without those things which essentially belong to
love, to love God; because it is an indispensable obligation that lies on men at all times, and
in all circumstances, to love God: but yet it is not a duty to love God without loving him, or
continuing without those things which essentially belong to his love. It is the duty of those
who have no sense of the loveliness of God and have no esteem of him, to love him, and
they are not in the least excused, by the want of this sense and esteem in not loving him one
moment; but yet it would be properly nonsense to say it is their duty to love him, without
any sense of his loveliness, or esteem of him. It is indeed their duty this moment to come
out of their disesteem, and stupid wicked insensibility of his loveliness, and to love him. I
made the distinction (I thought) very plainly, in the midst of those sentences you quote as
exceptionable. I say expressly, p. 74, ‘It is truly the duty of those who are in darkness, to
come out of darkness into light and believe; but, that they should confidently believe and
trust, while they yet remain without spiritual light or sight, is an anti-scriptural and absurd
doctrine.’ The misunderstanding between us, dear Sir, I suppose to be in the different ap-
plication of the particle without, in my use of it, and your understanding of it, or what we
understand as spoken of and supposed in the expression, without spiritual light or sight. As
I use it, I apply it to the act of believing, and I suppose it to be very absurd to talk of an act
of faith without spiritual light or sight, wherein I suppose you will allow me to be in the
lxxxviii
right. As you understand it, it is applied to duty or obligation, and you suppose it to be not
at all absurd, to talk of an obligation to believe without spiritual light or sight, but that the
obligation remains full, where there is no spiritual light or sight, wherein I allow you are in
the right. I think, Sir, if you read what I have said in my book on this head again, it will be
exceedingly apparent to you, that it is thus that I apply the preposition without, and not as
you before understood it. I thought I had very plainly manifested, that what I meant by being
in darkness was being in spiritual blindness, and so in a dead, stupid, and unchristian frame,
and not what is commonly called being without the light of God’s countenance, under the
175
CHAPTER XIV. Mistakes extensively prevalent at this time, as to the nature…