cannot be perceived but according to his reputation, whether that be true or false." Augustin
does not fail to crowd him for the change of base. The favorite passages of Ps. cxli. 5, Jer.
xv. 18, and Ecclus. xxxiv. 31, are gone over. Then he answers the charge made by
Cresconius, as to the right of any sinner to baptize among the Catholics. Finally, he reviews
Cyprian’s relation to rebaptism, who is not a canonical authority for him; the Scriptures
alone are such; but the Donatists ought to consider that decision of his to remain in unity
from the fact that the mixed nature of its membership requires toleration.
Book III. Augustin contends that the Donatists by their schism from especially the
Eastern churches had violated the principle of toleration, which their boasted leader had so
strenuously enforced. There follows then a seriatim consideration of the points made by
Cresconius, similar to those maintained by Petilian, as to the importance of the origin and
the head and root in baptism, or the character of the celebrant, and the rebaptism by Paul
of John’s disciples. The case of Optatus and the Maximianists next come under review, as
witnesses against their testimonies. Cresconius says he will neither absolve nor condemn
Optatus, and as to the Maximianists, he professes to have made special inquiry into the
whole history. The Synod had granted a season of delay during which all who returned
should be held innocent. Of this very many availed themselves; the baptism of these was
387
valid; those who remained outside lost both baptism and the church. Augustin refutes the
statement from its inherent contradictions and from the language of the Synod against the
Maximianists. Cresconius also brings forward the Sardican council’s letter to Donatus as
a proof of sustained fellowship. Augustin declares it to be an Arian council; and he insists
on paralleling all Cresconius would say about Cæcilianism with the career of the Maximian-
ists. With reference to persecution, he cites in extenso their own persecutions, the case of
Severus, bishop of Thubursicubur; the acts of Optatus; his own treatment at a collation by
the Circumcelliones; the case of Crispinus, the Donatist bishop of Calama; their own invoc-
ation of the state against the Maximianists. Thence he returns to the doctrine of the unity
as universal with many of the familiar Scripture texts, and asserts by the documents that
the Donatists were the occasion of the rupture.
Book IV. is a review of Cresconius’s work by the light of the Maximianist records. Be-
ginning with a pleasantry as to their eloquence and dialectic spirit, he follows in detail the
points of Cresconius whether doctrinal or historical as to Cæcilian, mainly with Maximianist
data as offsets. Cresconius charges Augustin with having called Petilian Satan, and so viol-
ating the peace he professes. Augustin claims that he only compared the error not the person,
to Satan. Nor had Cresconius forgotten to bring out the Manichæism of his opponent.
Augustin reminds him both of what he had written against them and also of what sins were
forgiven in the return of Maximian, who was an old man when Augustin was but young;
these were the sins of his youth. The theories of fellowship, of persecution, of baptism, are
666
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.