deeds of guilty parties which either cannot be proved to those who are innocent, or cannot
be believed by them, bring no stain upon any one, since, even when known, they are borne
with in order to preserve fellowship with those who are innocent. For the good are not to
be deserted for the sake of the wicked, but the wicked are to be borne with for the sake of
the good; as the prophets bore with those against whom they delivered such testimonies,
and did not cease to take part in the sacraments of the Jewish people; as also our Lord bore
with guilty Judas, even until he met the end which he deserved, and permitted him to take
part in the sacred supper along with the innocent disciples; as the apostles bore with those
who preached Christ through envy,—a sin peculiarly satanic;2173 as Cyprian bore with col-
leagues guilty of avarice, which, after the example of the apostle,2174 he calls idolatry. In
fine, whatever was done at that time among these bishops, although perhaps it was known
by some of them, is, unless there be respect of persons in judgment, unknown to all: why,
then, is not peace loved by all? These thoughts might easily occur to you; perhaps you already
entertain them. But it would be better for you to be devoted to earthly possessions, through
388
fear of losing which you might be proved to consent to known truth, than to be devoted to
that worthless vainglory which you think you will by such consent forfeit in the estimation
of men.
Chap. V.
16. You now see therefore, I suppose, that the thing to be considered when any one is
coerced, is not the mere fact of the coercion, but the nature of that to which he is coerced,
whether it be good or bad: not that any one can be good in spite of his own will, but that,
through fear of suffering what he does not desire, he either renounces his hostile prejudices,
or is compelled to examine truth of which he had been contentedly ignorant; and under the
influence of this fear repudiates the error which he was wont to defend, or seeks the truth
of which he formerly knew nothing, and now willingly holds what he formerly rejected.
Perhaps it would be utterly useless to assert this in words, if it were not demonstrated by so
many examples. We see not a few men here and there, but many cities, once Donatist, now
Catholic, vehemently detesting the diabolical schism, and ardently loving the unity of the
Church; and these became Catholic under the influence of that fear which is to you so of-
fensive by the laws of emperors, from Constantine, before whom your party of their own
accord impeached Cæcilianus, down to the emperors of our own time, who most justly decree
that the decision of the judge whom your own party chose, and whom they preferred to a
tribunal of bishops, should be maintained in force against you.
17. I have therefore yielded to the evidence afforded by these instances which my col-
leagues have laid before me. For originally my opinion was, that no one should be coerced
2173 Phil. i. 15, 18.
2174 Col. iii. 5.
856
To Vincentius